PPPK Salary Crisis Evidence of Regional Government Reform Failure
The Evident Institute assesses that the phenomenon of many local governments reporting an inability to pay the salaries of Government Employees with Work Agreements (PPSK) is clear evidence of a failure of reform at the regional level.
Executive Director of the Evident Institute, Rinatania Anggraeni Fajriani, stated that local government complaints regarding budget constraints for PPPK cannot be simplified merely through the narrative of fiscal pressure from the central government, such as cuts to Regional Transfers (TKD) or Revenue Sharing Funds (DBH).
“The failure of local governments to finance PPPK is an indication of much larger problems that we have been building slowly over the last 25 years,” Rinatania asserted in her statement on Monday.
Evident noted that in this controversy, one rarely discussed fact is that regional PPPK are recruited based on the local government’s own formation proposals. In principle, the financing is the fiscal responsibility of the Regional Budget (APBD). Therefore, when dozens of regions claim they are unable to pay, the problem is much deeper than just a reduction in central transfers.
In several regions, local governments even spend more than half of their APBD solely on personnel expenditure, despite very limited regional fiscal capacity. Rinatania believes that the proposal for a temporary relaxation of the 30% maximum limit on personnel expenditure should be considered as a short-term solution to maintain public services.
“However, relaxation must not become an excuse to repeat the same mistakes. The next step is that PPPK recruitment must be evaluated gradually, taking into account the fiscal dynamics of each region,” she added.
Since the 1998 Reformation, Indonesia has implemented fiscal decentralisation, where the central government sends trillions of rupiah through DAU, DAK, DBH, and Village Funds. Local governments possess full autonomy to regulate their regional policies.
Rinatania questioned why, after a quarter of a century of receiving significant transfers, dozens of regions are still unable to pay their own employees. She highlighted an imbalance in how reform is interpreted, noting that demands for transparency and accountability are almost always directed solely at the central government.
“Every policy decision made in Jakarta is brutally monitored by the public. The question is, when was the last time we demanded the same standard of accountability from local governments?” she said.
Dependence on central transfers remains very high despite the granting of fiscal autonomy. Consequently, as soon as efficiencies occur in central transfers, regions immediately face a crisis. Evident assesses that the 1998 reform succeeded in distributing authority but failed to ensure the institutional capacity of regions to manage that authority effectively.
In addition to the capacity issue, Rinatania also touched upon the sensitive issue of regional corruption. Decentralisation, which is intended to bring the state closer to the people, in practice often gives rise to ‘little kings’ with significant budget control but weak public oversight.
KPK enforcement data consistently shows that regional heads are among the groups with the highest levels of involvement in corruption. Ironically, many regions continue to receive Unqualified Opinions (WTP) from the BPK even though their officials are subsequently caught in corruption cases.
“The emergence of the problem where 39 regions cannot pay PPPK is not solely a matter of fiscal transfers. For 25 years, we have been too busy demanding reform of the central government, but we have normalised the failure of regional government reform,” she concluded.
Professor Djohermansyah Djohan from IPDN believes that the issue of 39 regions struggling to pay PPPK salaries is the responsibility of the central government. He hopes the central government can consider the financial capacity of regions regarding personnel expenditure.
The West Java Provincial Government has denied claims that it lacks funds to pay part-time PPPK salaries by January 2026. Meanwhile, the South Sulawesi Provincial Government emphasised that the budget allocation for PPPK salaries is included in the RPJMD documents, as stated by the Head of Bappelitbangda South Sulawesi, Dr Setiawan Aswad.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/pppk-salary-crisis-evidence-of-regional-government-reform-failure-1782809452)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/905816/krisis-gaji-pppk-bukti-kegagalan-reformasi-pemda), translated from Indonesian