Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Power to the people

| Source: The Jakarta Post

Power to the people

Today is a very important day for Indonesia. For the first
time since the country proclaimed its independence in 1945, we
Indonesians will have a chance to directly elect our president
and vice president. For the first time, the people, through a
democratic election, will be able to choose which of the five
pairs of candidates should lead the country for the next five
years. The power to choose our leaders is in our hands, and the
time to do this is today.

Prior to this year, we had eight general elections, although
only two really count as meeting the basic requirements of a
free, fair and democratic poll. We have had five presidents, none
of which was elected directly by the people. That privilege went
to the People's Consultative Assembly (MPR), which comprised
elected as well as appointed representatives. The power to choose
the country's leaders was, until now, in their hands.

In most political theories, direct and indirect elections have
both advantages and disadvantages. Neither is necessarily more
democratic nor better than the other. It depends ultimately on
implementation. The United States, as one of the most advanced
democracies, chooses its president through an electoral college.
France, which also uses a presidential system of government,
employs a direct election method. Our founding fathers opted for
the indirect system because they perceived that this was most
suitable for a pluralist and diverse nation like ours. The
intention was to ensure all groups in society were represented in
the country's political processes, including in the election of
its president.

Alas, the system was abused by our first two presidents,
Sukarno and Soeharto, who manipulated the composition of the MPR
to ensure their reelection. Even in 1999, when Indonesia held its
first democratic election since 1955, the system was abused:
Horse-trading between MPR factions robbed Megawati Soekarnoputri
of the presidency, even though her Indonesian Democratic Party of
Struggle (PDI-P) had won the general election. She settled for
the vice presidency but became president in 2001 only after the
same MPR had impeached Abdurrahman Wahid, putting her in his
place.

After that long and bitter experience with the indirect
elections system, it became a matter of national consensus that
the power to elect the president and vice president should be
given to the people. In the spirit of the sweeping political
reform that came in the wake of the 1998 collapse of the Soeharto
regime, the country decided on a direct presidential elections
system. The Constitution has been amended and this year
Indonesians go to the polls twice. The first occasion was in
April to elect the House of Representatives and the Regional
Representatives Council. Today, July 5, we shall vote for our
president.

Politicians, particularly from the major political parties,
have obviously retained some control. They designed the elections
legislation, and retained the power to nominate candidates. The
law precludes the emergence of an independent candidate. However,
while the large political parties may control the process, they
cannot control the outcome. That is entirely in the hands of the
electorate.

We leave it to political scientists to debate whether a direct
presidential elections system is better and more democratic.
Later, historians will probably be able to judge more fairly
whether we have taken the right course in the way we elect our
leaders. What is clear at present for Indonesia is that the power
to choose our leaders is now in the hands of the people.

For what it is worth, voters today have five pairs of
candidates from which to choose. The candidates campaigned for
much of the past month, explained their platforms at length, made
multiple promises and entertained the people as a way of winning
votes. Last week, they bravely appeared in a nationally televised
public dialog -- again, a new tradition in the country's
electoral history. To their credit, the campaign period was
relatively peaceful, and allegations of cheating minimal.

We reserve the greatest praise, however, for the Indonesian
people. We should rejoice at our achievement in forging ahead
with democracy, even though the economic environment or security
situation are not all that positive.

Whatever the outcome of today's election, the nation can take
pride that it is contributing to making democracy work in this
country: Three cheers for democracy.

More from 5 July 2004 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/power-to-the-people-1447893297-1504937)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print