Power of capital in decentralization
Power of capital in decentralization
The following is the second of two articles on cities
undergoing decentralization by architect and urban expert Marco
Kusumawijaya.
JAKARTA (JP): The fact that none of the intended superblocks
were completed in Jakarta by the time the economic crisis began,
indicated that the developers' ambitions contradicted the system
of a super-block itself.
Such a huge entity requires long-term sustainable stability
that would ultimately be destroyed by the competition that it
created, resulting in overheated speculation.
We have become only too familiar with a property business
dominated by speculation and bad debts that has largely
contributed to the wider economic crisis in Jakarta.
Can this situation be improved? Maybe. But there are
alternatives in the form of citizen movements that do not aim at
changing the system, but at checking and correcting it.
This alternative harnesses the one unquestioned strength of
decentralization, where the decision making process is brought
closer to the stakeholders. The key term for this is "public
participation", which is the prerequisite for continuously
innovative and creative policies.
Popular participation is urgent for at least two reasons. The
first is Indonesia's transitional condition -- which needs to
accommodate plurality and reduce the gap between members of the
elite and the rest of society.
The second is the need to balance representative democracy
which, across the world, is deemed insufficient for a fast
changing world.
The sociologist Manuel Castells describes "urban movements" as
"the processes of purposive social mobilization, organized in a
given territory, oriented toward urban-related goals".
Observing historic moments in the late 1970s and early 1980s,
he says that urban movements have become a critical source of
resistance to the one-sided logic of capitalism, the predominant
role of the state, and informationalism, or the dependency on
information flow and power over information in governance and in
the economy.
Urban movements in Europe, at that time, began to emerge from
general discontent with the established lifestyle.
This was essentially because the failure of proactive
movements -- such as the labor movement and political parties --
to counter economic exploitation, cultural domination, and
political oppression, had driven people to react on the basis of
their respective localities.
There are three main sets of goals for urban movements to
focus on: urban demands on living conditions and collective
consumption; the affirmation of local cultural identity; and the
conquest of local political autonomy and citizen participation.
In this context four main trajectories of the movements are
synthesized: the integration of these movements into the
structure and practice of local government; the nurturing of
local communities as part of the environmental movement; the
engagement of poor communities in collective survival offering
reactive utopias -- dreams which develop as a reaction to deep
dissatisfaction, leading to resistance.
The first trajectory tends to strengthen local government, and
will enhance inter-city competition. The fourth can become
destructive if urban movements' appeals are not heard, if the new
political avenues remain closed and if relatively new social
movements such as feminism and new labor do not develop fully.
These are the conditions which we fear will come true with the
increasingly uncertain development of the reform movement.
However, besides the problems posed by decentralization,
villages to metropolises are also bursting from the inside. A
high rate of urbanization has not been supported by a compatible
urban culture.
The problem of Indonesian cities is not only in having to
survive competition among each other, but also in developing
themselves to at least reach minimum standards that are
acceptable to their inhabitants and users.
Rapid urbanization has given little chance to develop urban
order and a culture capable of dealing with contemporary
conditions. Nowadays, Indonesians need to make the best use of
the reform moment, to learn how to urbanize quickly, wisely and
smartly.
We have the advantage of being latecomers. One thing that
could make a difference is to widen the urbanization debate to
include all segments in society.
The debate should also be enlarged to involve the arts,
literature, architecture, and other cultural spheres besides the
traditional technical and economic framework.
Awareness and conception about urbanization could be based on
broad-based consensus. This is essential to reach a collectively
acceptable concept and vision of urban civilization in Indonesia,
whatever that may be.
An urban civilization needs to be developed proactively. Plans
need to be drafted and carried out based on a clear "urban
cultural strategy" for a better future, when most Indonesians
will inhabit cities and the rest will use them intensely.
Participation and urban movements are ways to galvanize open-
ended and rooted urban societies that can never be monopolized,
reduced, or manipulated by any regime.
Social and cultural entities, through participation and urban
movements will counterbalance top-down imposition of a
homogeneous structure.
The urban kampongs must be strengthened, not only as housing
areas to balance over-speculation of the property business, but
also as enriching autonomous dwelling cultures to resist the
powerful tendency of homogenization.
With healthy activism, even sporadic and small sized non-
governmental organizations and civil society groups are very
important, especially if they are able to develop an ever
critical stance through sustained exchange of ideas and
experiences.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/power-of-capital-in-decentralization-1447893297-1094250)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post