Poor People's Network Urges State to Stop Distributing Land to Individuals
Six organisations comprising the Indonesian Poor People’s Network presented several proposals during the drafting of the Agrarian Reform Regulation Bill at the House of Representatives’ Legislative Body (Baleg) in Jakarta on Thursday (10/9).
During the meeting, coalition representative Guntoro Gugun Muhammad proposed that the government cease the practice of distributing land title certificates to the public on an individual basis.
Guntoro expressed pessimism that the current method would resolve land rights inequality or improve public welfare. “If agrarian reform aims to address or reduce inequality, but the state’s policy remains to distribute land to individuals, I am pessimistic,” Gugun stated during the meeting with lawmakers.
He explained that although current regulations prohibit the sale of gifted land for 10 years, this is not the reality in practice. According to Guntoro, many people engage in under-the-table transactions to sell their land.
“Even though there is a 10-year prohibition on transfers, under-the-table transfers can still occur, eventually returning the land to the market,” he said.
Guntoro proposed that agrarian reform policies should be implemented through collective certificates. He noted that this should not be an optional choice left to the discretion of the community.
“If citizens are asked whether they want individual or collective certificates, they will certainly choose individual ones. Therefore, it cannot be an option,” he argued.
However, Guntoro suggested that if this cannot be implemented nationally, collective land certificates should at least be enforced in urban areas. He provided several reasons for this necessity.
Firstly, Guntoro explained that rapid urban spatial changes and high land prices cause communities to lose their land even faster. Secondly, individual ownership will not lead to prosperity even if the gifted land is eventually sold, as the size of the land titles received is often too small.
He argued that collective ownership could be more easily empowered. “If individualised, it might only be 36 square metres. But if combined, it could become 1 hectare. In that way, the land can be managed together, and businesses can be established collectively for welfare,” he said.
The Agrarian Reform Bill was passed in a plenary session of the House of Representatives earlier this week as an initiative from the legislative body to be enacted into law.
One of the key points to be discussed is the formation of the National Agrarian Reform Agency (BRAN).
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/poor-peoples-network-urges-state-to-stop-distributing-land-to-individuals-1789152656)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260911091622-20-1402666/jejaring-rakyat-miskin-minta-negara-setop-bagi-bagi-tanah-ke-individu), translated from Indonesian