Political Satay: When Everyone Becomes Part of the Power Structure
In 1932, Mohammad Hatta wrote a critique of the idea of unity gaining ground in the national movement. In an article entitled “Persatuan Ditjari, Per-sate-an Jang Ada” in the daily Daulat Ra’jat, Hatta mocked the tendency to unite different groups without considering their differing principles and interests. To him, such unity was no more than satay: buffalo, beef and goat meat could be skewered on the same stick, but that did not make them the same kind of meat. This kind of unity, he argued, risked sacrificing the principles of each group.
Nearly a century later, Hatta’s critique has found new relevance in Indonesia’s political landscape. Under President Prabowo Subianto, power has been consolidated through a broad coalition, a large cabinet and the inclusion of political forces that previously held different positions and interests. Is this simply a strategy for building a stable government, or does it reveal the kind of political “satay” Hatta once questioned?
This question matters not because every political alliance should be viewed with suspicion, but because unity that leaves no room for difference can itself become a problem for democracy.
From unity to the accommodation of power
Since the start of his administration, Prabowo has shown a tendency to build broad political support. The Merah Putih Cabinet, announced in October 2024, initially comprised 48 ministries; the updated government profile later listed 49. This makes it one of the largest government structures under Prabowo, compared with the previous cabinet’s 34 ministries.
The size of the cabinet does not, in itself, prove that power is being distributed to serve elite interests. A country with a vast territory and complex development challenges needs an effective government structure. Likewise, in a multiparty presidential system, building a coalition is one way to secure political support for government programmes.
But the issue goes beyond administrative needs or political legitimacy. We must also ask how the coalition was formed, which interests have been brought together, and what effect this has on the independence of political parties.
A healthy coalition should bring political forces together through agreement on programmes, a division of responsibilities and commitments for which they can be held publicly accountable. By contrast, a coalition risks becoming little more than elite accommodation when proximity to power matters more than consistency in programmes and principles.
This is where Hatta’s critique becomes relevant. He was not merely concerned with how many groups were being united, but with what happened to each group’s principles in the process. In today’s context, the question can be reframed: do parties joining the government still maintain an independent position, or are their differences becoming less significant because of their shared interests in power?
This cannot be answered simply by counting the parties supporting the government. However, the broader the consolidation of power, the more important it is to ensure that oversight and scrutiny continue to function.
Bringing in or taming?
In political science, the concept of co-optation describes the process by which potential opponents are drawn into structures or mechanisms that can reduce the challenge they pose to those in power. Conflict is not always confronted openly; it can be dampened by giving those previously outside the circle of power access, positions or particular interests.
This concept can be used to examine Prabowo’s political strategy. However, it should be stressed that inclusion does not automatically amount to co-optation. A figure who joins the government may have substantive reasons, share its agenda or want to improve policy from within. Conversely, joining the government does not guarantee that someone will lose their independence.
The more important measure, therefore, is not simply who has secured a position, but how that new role affects their political stance.
Can a party that was previously critical still dare to reject government policy when it believes that policy harms the public? Can academics who enter the power structure retain the freedom to criticise decisions that conflict with their expertise? Can officials voice objections openly without worrying about political consequences?
These questions are more meaningful than merely guessing a president’s motives or accusing everyone who joins the government of abandoning their principles.
If inclusion causes these groups to lose their ability to hold power to account, there is reason to speak of co-optation. Conversely, if they remain able to take a critical stance and fulfil their responsibilities independently, inclusion alone is not enough to call it taming.
Co-optation should therefore be treated as a possibility to be tested through political behaviour and institutional consequences, rather than as a conclusion that automatically follows from the size of a coalition.
When opposition loses its place
The more fundamental concern about the consolidation of power is the possibility that opposition will be weakened.
In a democracy, opposition is not simply a group that rejects every government policy. It is part of the mechanism through which power can be monitored, criticised and corrected. Parties outside government can perform this function, but parties supporting the government should also have room to voice objections and reject policies that run counter to the public interest.
Problems arise when nearly all political forces see proximity to the government as more advantageous than maintaining a critical distance. In such circumstances, political differences risk becoming merely symbolic. Competition continues, but the ability to correct the decisions of those in power diminishes.
Of course, a large coalition does not automatically erase democracy. Broad parliamentary support can help a government implement its programmes. But that support must also be balanced by effective oversight from parliament, relevant state institutions, the press, academics and civil society.
Without adequate mechanisms for scrutiny, stability can become a source of comfort for those in power. The government may find it easier to make decisions, but that ease does not necessarily mean the decisions are sound or serve the public.
Democracy needs more than a strong government. It also needs forces willing to say that the government may be wrong.
This is where Hatta’s critique of political “satay” can be revisited. When all groups become part of one political unity, we must ensure that it does not erase the differences needed to keep the political struggle on course.
Rereading Hatta’s critique
From this perspective, the central issue is not whether Prabowo has succeeded in bringing many political groups together. It is whether this inclusion has produced cooperation that respects differences in principle, or instead created a unity that strips those differences of their power to correct.
If those joining the government can maintain their independence, criticise policy and carry out oversight, a large coalition cannot automatically be called political “satay”. But if the desire to retain access to power leads them to sacrifice their principles and abandon their oversight role, Hatta’s critique becomes increasingly relevant.
Who is still willing to stand outside?
Hatta warned that unity cannot be built simply by placing different groups in the same container. Unity that disregards differences in principle produces togetherness only on the surface, while conflicts of interest persist beneath it.
In a democracy, differences are not something that must always be dissolved. They can instead be a source of scrutiny and improvement. The government needs support to function, but society needs room to criticise it. Political parties may form coalitions, but coalitions should not make differences of opinion meaningless.
So, if Hatta’s critique of political “satay” is to be used to interpret the Prabowo administration, the central question is not whether everyone can sit together. It is whether they still have the courage to disagree when the interests of power demand conformity.
Ultimately, democracy is not measured by how many political forces a president manages to bring into his fold, but by how far the power he builds can still be monitored, criticised and corrected. Healthy unity does not require everyone to lose their voice. Rather, it makes room for differences to remain alive.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/political-satay-when-everyone-becomes-part-of-the-power-structure-1794225081)
Originally published by Republika (https://retizen.republika.co.id/posts/791968/persatean-politik-ketika-semua-menjadi-bagian-dari-kekuasaan), translated from Indonesian