Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Political deadlock hampers peace three years after Gaza conflict

| Source: Antara (Indonesian) Translated from Indonesian | Politics
Political deadlock hampers peace three years after Gaza conflict
Image: Antara (Indonesian)

Cairo (ANTARA) — Three years after the Gaza conflict erupted on 7 October 2023, the coastal enclave lies in ruins and tens of thousands of people have been killed.

Although a ceasefire has been reached, fundamental deadlock remains unresolved.

Analysts, quoted by Xinhua, say irreconcilable differences between Palestinian and Israeli demands, compounded by perceived US bias, are making a comprehensive settlement and lasting peace difficult to achieve. The war has also had far-reaching regional consequences, with instability spreading to Lebanon, Syria, Iran and the Red Sea.

On 7 October 2023, Hamas launched Operation Al-Aqsa Flood, firing thousands of rockets from Gaza and sending fighters into southern Israel. About 1,200 people were killed and around 250 were taken hostage.

Israel then declared war and launched Operation Swords of Iron, striking Gaza from the air and advancing by land in a campaign that became a prolonged and devastating conflict.

Over the past three years, Gaza has suffered extensive destruction, bringing a profound humanitarian disaster across the territory. More than 74,000 people have been killed in the enclave since 7 October 2023, according to Gaza health authorities.

“Israel’s massive military campaign has caused a very high death toll, particularly among women and children, widespread destruction of homes and infrastructure, and the displacement of more than two million Palestinians,” said Bahraini political analyst Abdullah Al Huwaihi.

Amid growing international condemnation over the loss of life in Gaza, a ceasefire was finally reached in October 2025.

Under the first phase of the US-proposed Gaza ceasefire plan, Israeli forces were required to withdraw to the “Yellow Line” and exchange hostages for prisoners. The second phase, launched in mid-January, focused on demilitarising Gaza and establishing a technocratic government.

By the end of July, Hamas had agreed to include the surrender of heavy weapons in the demilitarisation arrangements, on condition that Israel withdraw all its forces and end its “aggression”.

However, the phased agreement failed to deliver lasting peace. Khaled Al Hroub, a professor of international conflict at Northwestern University in Qatar, said the failure of successive frameworks showed that a genuine settlement required going beyond managing recurring violence and addressing the conflict’s political roots.

As Gaza has been devastated, violence and the loss of Palestinian territory in the West Bank have also intensified.

UN data show that, as of 10 August, about 3,800 Palestinians had been displaced by settler violence, home demolitions and evictions. The UN recorded more than 1,430 settler-related incidents so far this year, affecting around 260 Palestinian communities.

“The West Bank is on the brink of collapse,” said Ramiz Alakbarov, the UN humanitarian co-ordinator for the occupied Palestinian territory.

Analysts attribute the prolonged deadlock in Gaza to unresolved disagreements between Israel and Hamas.

Akram Attaallah, a political analyst from Gaza, said Israel insists Hamas disarm completely before a full troop withdrawal, while Hamas demands an end to Israeli military operations and a total Israeli withdrawal before discussing the question of weapons.

“Israel and Hamas view the issue as a complete winner-takes-all situation. Hamas wants to remain, while Israel wants to eliminate every form of Hamas presence in the Gaza Strip,” he said. “Between these two positions, the crisis continues.”

Adel al-Ghurairi, a professor at the University of Baghdad, said the US-proposed framework — including the so-called “Board of Peace”, a stabilisation force and a transitional committee — remained largely on paper, while disarmament and the withdrawal of Israeli forces were still pending.

“The key elements of the roadmap — disarmament, Israel’s withdrawal and who will govern during the transitional period — all remain unresolved,” he said.

Behind the scenes, the US is playing a highly contradictory role, analysts told Xinhua.

Ali Al Hail, a professor of political science at Qatar University, said Washington’s role as the main mediator was undermined by its military aid and diplomatic support for Israel. This raised questions about its neutrality and enabled the conflict to continue.

“The US is playing a dual role: it remains Israel’s principal strategic ally while also being a key actor in diplomatic efforts,” he said. “This dual position raises questions about how effectively it can act as a mediator acceptable to all sides.”

Al-Ghurairi added that the US wanted the war to end but had not shown the resolve to make that outcome a reality. “The absence of a genuine multilateral mechanism, and reliance on US unilateral dominance, make any settlement fragile,” he said.

Across the region, analysts say the conflict has significantly altered the geopolitical landscape.

Sudanese political analyst Mohamed Amin said the conflict’s regional impact had reached the Red Sea, where Yemen’s Houthi movement had attacked ships in support of the Palestinian people.

“This has made some of the war’s consequences in Gaza a matter of international shipping and trade security,” he said.

The balance of power between the US-Israeli alliance and the Iran-led axis of resistance, which includes Hamas, the Houthis and Lebanon’s Hezbollah, has shifted, Al Huwaihi added.

“Israel believes that, following what it considers a success in Gaza, the confrontation should be directed at Iran, the main state sponsor of these groups,” he said. “Israel then succeeded in persuading the US president to launch a war against Iran on 28 February.”

Amid these complexities, a widely held view is that genuine and lasting peace remains impossible without the full implementation of a two-state solution and the restoration of Palestinians’ legitimate rights.

Lebanese political analyst Youssef Diab said the Palestinian issue would likely remain the central conflict shaping regional dynamics.

“The choices are peace for the Palestinian people, including the establishment of a sovereign Palestinian state with real authority, or continued instability and chaos,” Diab said.

“Regional stability will also depend on the ability of regional states and international powers to defuse interconnected tensions in Iran, Yemen, the Red Sea and the Gulf, and to build a broader security and political order,” Amin added.

More from 9 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/political-deadlock-hampers-peace-three-years-after-gaza-conflict-1791532501)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5778268/kebuntuan-politik-hambat-perdamaian-setelah-tiga-tahun-konflik-gaza), translated from Indonesian
Print