Police Say Roy Suryo's Lawsuit Is Misguided: Not a Matter for Pretrial
Polda Metro Jaya has delivered its response in the pre-trial hearing of Roy Suryo’s lawsuit challenging his suspect status in the case of alleged defamation over the fake degree of Indonesia’s seventh president, Joko Widodo (Jokowi). In its response, Polda Metro stated that Roy Suryo’s lawsuit concerns the substance of the case and therefore falls outside the realm of pre-trial proceedings.
The pre-trial hearing of Roy Suryo’s lawsuit against his suspect status, issued by Polda Metro Jaya, was held at the South Jakarta District Court on Monday (13/7/2026). Polda Metro’s legal team stated at the outset that the process from inquiry and investigation through to the handover to prosecutors had complied with the applicable rules.
“In carrying out these obligations, the Respondent conducted the inquiry and investigation stages in a structured and documented manner, from the collection of evidence, the examination of witnesses and experts, the seizure of relevant evidence, case reviews, the designation of a suspect based on valid evidence, through to coordination with the Public Prosecutor via the pre-prosecution mechanism, in accordance with Law Number 8 of 1981,” the Polda Metro legal team explained at the hearing.
Polda Metro said investigators already held three pieces of evidence. It added that investigators had also examined Roy Suryo before designating him as a suspect.
“In the case at hand, the Respondent designated the Petitioner as a suspect after obtaining at least two valid pieces of evidence as required under Article 184, and after first examining the Petitioner as a prospective suspect, so that the requirements set by Constitutional Court Decision Number 21 have been fulfilled,” the Polda Metro legal team said.
Polda Metro’s legal team said the case was a follow-up to several police reports concerning alleged defamation, slander and suspected electronic information manipulation relating to Jokowi’s undergraduate degree, which were circulated on social media. One of the reports was filed directly by Jokowi on 30 April 2025.
Polda Metro Jaya’s legal team also addressed Roy Suryo’s challenge regarding the application of Article 32 paragraph (1) of Law Number 11 of 2008 as amended by Law Number 19 of 2016 on Electronic Information and Transactions (the ITE Law). The team argued that this challenge concerned the substance of the case, not pre-trial matters.
“The Petitioner is in principle entitled to object to legal actions, including through the pre-trial mechanism. However, this does not make the Petitioner the party authorised to determine or declare on his own that the application of a particular article against him is improper, let alone to claim that there has been a smuggling of charges without a material examination of the evidence at the main trial,” the legal team explained.
“The assessment of whether a person’s act fulfils or does not fulfil the elements of the alleged article, including Article 32 paragraph (1) of the ITE Law, constitutes the substance of the case. That realm lies within the authority of the panel of judges at the main trial, not the single pre-trial judge,” it added.
The following is the response read out by Polda Metro Jaya’s legal team:
To reject the Petitioner’s pre-trial application in its entirety.
To declare that the suspect designation made by the Respondent, based on the decree on the designation of a suspect number S.Tap/S-4/1899/XI/2025/Ditreskrimum Polda Metro Jaya dated 7 November 2025 in the name of K.R.M.T. Roy Suryo Notodiprojo, is lawful.
To declare that all investigative actions taken by the Respondent, based on:
A. Investigation Order Sp.Sidik/S-1.1/3147/VII/2025/Ditreskrimum Polda Metro Jaya dated 14 July 2025;
B. Investigation Order Sp.Sidik/94/I/Res.1.14/2026/Ditreskrimum Polda Metro Jaya dated 15 January 2026;
C. Investigation Order Sp.Sidik/1043/III/Res.1.14/2026/Ditreskrimum Polda Metro Jaya dated 30 March 2026;
D. Investigation Order Sp.Sidik/1270/IV/Res.1.14/2026/Ditreskrimum Polda Metro Jaya dated 15 April 2026, are lawful.
- To order the Petitioner to bear the court costs, or in accordance with the applicable law.
Should the Honourable Single Pre-Trial Judge examining and adjudicating the case hold a different opinion, we request the fairest possible judgment (ex aequo et bono).
Earlier, Roy Suryo’s side read out the petitum of the pre-trial application. Its contents were as follows:
To grant the Petitioner’s pre-trial application in its entirety.
To declare that the designation of the Petitioner as a suspect under Article 32 paragraph (1) of Law Number 11 of 2008 as last amended by Law Number 1 of 2024 on the ITE Law, made by the Respondent on the basis of Decree Number S.Tap/S-4/1899/XI/2025/Ditreskrimum/Polda Metro Jaya concerning the suspect designation dated 7 November 2025, is unlawful because it was carried out unlawfully, namely in violation of Constitutional Court Decision Number 21/PUU-XII/2014 of 28 April 2015 read together with Article 184 paragraph (1) of Law Number 8 of 1981, the old Criminal Procedure Code.
To declare that the Petitioner cannot be charged under Article 32 paragraph (1) of Law Number 11 of 2008 as last amended by Law Number 1 of 2024, the ITE Law.
To declare that the investigation conducted by the Respondent on the basis of Investigation Order Number SP.Sidik/S1.1/3147/VII/2025/Ditreskrimum Polda Metro Jaya dated 14 July 2025, Investigation Order Number SP.Sidik/94/I/2026/Ditreskrimum Polda Metro Jaya dated 15 January 2026, and Investigation Order Number SP.Sidik/1043/III/2026/Ditreskrimum Polda Metro Jaya dated 30 March 2026, is unlawful because it was carried out unlawfully, namely in violation of Constitutional Court Decision Number 21/PUU-XII/2014 of 24-28 April 2015 read together with Article 184 paragraph (1) of Law Number 8 of 1981, the old Criminal Procedure Code.
To order that:
A. Investigation Order Number SP.Sidik/S1.1/3147/VII/2025/Ditreskrimum Polda Metro Jaya dated 14 July 2025;
B. Investigation Order Number SP.Sidik/94/I/2026/Ditreskrimum Polda Metro Jaya dated 15 January 2026;
C. Investigation Order Number SP.Sidik/1043/III/2026/Ditreskrimum Polda Metro Jaya dated 30 March 2026;
D. Decree Number S.Tap/S-4/1899/XI/2025/Ditreskrimum Polda Metro Jaya concerning the suspect designation dated 7 November 2025, and/or any orders and/or documents issued by the Respondent based on the documents referred to in points A, B, C and D above, be annulled.
To restore the Petitioner’s honour, dignity and good name to their original state pursuant to Article 82 paragraph (3) letter d of the old Criminal Procedure Code, Law Number 8 of 1981.
To order the Respondent not to violate Article 163 paragraph (1) letter e of the new Criminal Procedure Code, Law Number 20 of 2025.
To declare that the Respondent shall comply with and submit to the judgment in this case.
To impose the court costs in accordance with the applicable regulations.
Or, should the Honourable Chief Judge of the South Jakarta District Court, c.q. the judge receiving and examining the pre-trial application in this case, hold a different opinion, we request the fairest possible judgment (ex aequo et bono).
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/police-say-roy-suryos-lawsuit-is-misguided-not-a-matter-for-pretrial-1783921992)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8571683/polisi-anggap-gugatan-roy-suryo-salah-alamat-bukan-ranah-praperadilan), translated from Indonesian