Police Criticised for Handing Over High-Profile Graft Case to Attorney General's Office
The decision by the Indonesian National Police to hand over the investigation into alleged corruption and money laundering involving former Junior Attorney General for Special Crimes (Jampidsus) Febrie Adriansyah to the Attorney General’s Office has raised significant questions. The Civil Society Forum (Forsiber) believes the move was taken just as the investigation was entering its most critical phase, before the main suspect was examined and the case’s construction was fully tested.
Forsiber Coordinator Hamdi Putra stated that the public has a right to know why the police relinquished control of the investigation at a stage that should determine the direction of the case’s evidence. “The police carried out the work that attracted the most public attention, but handed over to the Attorney General’s Office the work that will determine the fate of the case,” Hamdi said in a statement on Sunday.
According to Hamdi, the police had initially shown progressive steps. Investigators conducted searches, seized a fantastic amount of cash and gold, held a case conference, and then named Febrie Adriansyah a suspect for alleged corruption and/or money laundering related to the handling of the PT Asabri case and other corruption cases. Based on an official statement from the Head of the Police’s Corruption Eradication Corps, Febrie is charged under Article 12 letter e and Article 12B of the Corruption Eradication Law, Article 3 and Article 4 of the Money Laundering Law, or Article 607 paragraph (1) letters a and b of the new Criminal Code. In the same case, the police also named DR as a money laundering suspect and detained him at the Polda Metro Jaya detention centre.
However, Hamdi assessed that this courage was not followed by the completion of the investigation process. He argued that after naming Febrie a suspect, the police should have used their authority to examine him directly to test the relationship with DR, trace the origin of the seized money and gold, confirm the alleged use of nominees, and ensure the connection of all assets to the case under investigation. “The police appear brave in drawing legal conclusions, but do not complete the evidentiary confrontation with the accused,” he said.
He noted that the Attorney General’s Office’s statement that it would still develop evidence, maximise the seized assets, and ensure a causal link indicates the investigation was not complete when it was handed over. Therefore, the transfer is seen not merely as a handover of files, but a transfer of investigative control at the most decisive phase. This situation potentially weakens the legitimacy of the suspect designation made by the police. If the evidence was indeed strong enough, the investigation should have been completed up to the suspect’s examination and the compilation of the case file.
Conversely, if the case construction still needs to be built by the Attorney General’s Office, the public has the right to question how solid the basis was for the police to name Febrie a suspect. Another point of scrutiny arises because the investigation was handed over to the institution where Febrie once served as Jampidsus. Hamdi believes this situation objectively presents a risk of conflict of interest. The Attorney General’s Office may potentially have to examine a former leader, former subordinates, or the handling of cases that took place within its own institution. According to him, this risk does not mean the Attorney General’s Office has been proven to protect the suspect, but is a consequence arising from the structural, professional, and reputational relationship between the suspect and the institution now handling the investigation.
On the other hand, Hamdi also assessed that the police have not provided an explanation regarding the legal basis for the transfer of the investigation. It is not yet known whether the Attorney General’s Office issued a new investigation warrant, whether the investigation is being conducted jointly, or whether all authority has been fully transferred. The legal status of the suspects and the mechanism for controlling the evidence after the transfer have also not been explained to the public. He argued this lack of clarity opens space for shifting responsibility if the case does not progress. The police could claim the investigation has been handed over, while the Attorney General’s Office could state that the evidence received still needs to be completed.
Hamdi also questioned the undisclosed relationship between Febrie and DR. Although both have been named suspects, the police have not explained whether DR acted as a nominee, an asset custodian, a transaction manager, or had another role in the alleged money laundering. The same applies to the seized evidence. According to Hamdi, the large value of cash, gold, houses, and other assets does not automatically strengthen the case if investigators have not been able to explain the true ownership, the origin of the assets, the source of funds for purchases, and their connection to the alleged criminal act. He also highlighted the application of Article 12 letter e of the Corruption Law, which has not been accompanied by an explanation of the core of the alleged extortion, including who was allegedly forced, the form of pressure used, and the alleged benefits obtained.
Furthermore, Hamdi questioned the difference in treatment between the two suspects. DR has been detained, while there has been no public explanation regarding the examination or detention of Febrie. “The law must not appear swift and firm against private parties, but become overly cautious when dealing with a former high-ranking law enforcement official,” he said. Hamdi stressed that coordination between the police and the Attorney General’s Office is necessary. However, inter-agency synergy should not be used as a reason to obscure the division of authority or accountability for the investigation. “The police’s greatest weakness lies not in the courage to name Febrie Adriansyah a suspect, but in the decision to name a suspect, display the evidence, and then hand it over,” he concluded.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/police-criticised-for-handing-over-high-profile-graft-case-to-attorney-generals-office-1783839033)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/910014/polri-dinilai-lepas-momen-krusial), translated from Indonesian