Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Polemics over Civilian Posts in Police Law: Analyst Suggests Opponents File Constitutional Court Challenge

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Polemics over Civilian Posts in Police Law: Analyst Suggests Opponents File Constitutional Court Challenge
Image: Media Indonesia

Senior political analyst Boni Hargens has called on the public to dispel negative prejudice against the Indonesian National Police (Polri) regarding a new regulation that permits active police personnel to occupy civilian positions within ministries and government agencies. The statement was issued in response to a wave of strong rejection from the Civil Society Coalition for Police Reform against Article 28A of the revised Law Number 2 of 2002 on the National Police. The article opens the door for active members of the Bhayangkara Corps to fill civilian posts based on the President’s discretion or a request from the relevant ministry.

"If police personnel are indeed more competent for certain positions in the civilian realm, the involvement of Polri in civilian posts is a natural and legitimate necessity. We need not be overly prejudiced against the Polri institution. Moreover, Polri, as part of civil society, also has a responsibility to strengthen civilian democracy," Boni told reporters on Saturday (20/6/2026). Boni added that Polri’s commitment not to dominate the civilian bureaucracy has been affirmed by National Police Chief General Listyo Sigit Prabowo. The Chief stated that this rule is not coercive, but is entirely based on real needs and concrete requests from the ministry concerned.

To ensure the implementation of this new rule does not stray from the corridor of democracy, Boni offered a perspective comprising three main conditions that must be met. First, placement must be based on specific expertise relevant to the targeted civilian position. Second, the mechanism for filling positions must be purely based on agency requests, not unilateral forced placement by the police institution. Third, the placement must be viewed as a form of Polri’s constitutional contribution to strengthening the legal democracy system in Indonesia.

Boni assessed that this polemic reflects a fundamental tension between two viewpoints, both of which have strong arguments. On one side, supporters of the revision prioritise the principle of institutional pragmatism based on competence, while on the other side, civil society groups are concerned about potential conflicts of interest and the politicisation of the bureaucracy. Previously, sharp rejection was voiced by the Civil Society Coalition for Police Reform. Coalition representative Muhammad Isnur assessed that the new formulation of Article 28A of the Police Law potentially opens the door to widespread dual office-holding without clear limits and without requiring personnel to resign from active duty. The coalition argues that this provision contradicts the MPR Decree on the separation of police functions from the civilian realm and violates Constitutional Court Decision Number 114/PUU-XXIII/2025.

Responding to this unresolved constitutional law debate, Boni Hargens suggested that objecting parties pursue the available constitutional path. "I suggest that if the Civil Society Coalition holds a different view, they can submit a petition for a constitutional review of Article 28A to the Constitutional Court. Another thing that can be done is to ensure that the transparency and accountability mechanisms for placement are carefully designed," Boni concluded. Boni assessed that the new Police Law, including the strengthening of the National Police Commission within it, will facilitate the realisation of fundamental restoration within Polri. The police reform agenda requires consistent oversight so that it does not stop at the policy level but can be concretely implemented down to the lowest working units. National Police Chief General Listyo Sigit Prabowo stressed that the placement of Polri personnel in civilian posts must go through a request from the ministry or agency and an open bidding mechanism. Every active Polri personnel proposed must obtain a green light from the relevant ministry and pass the state apparatus competency scheme.

More from 20 June 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/polemics-over-civilian-posts-in-police-law-analyst-suggests-opponents-file-constitutional-court-challenge-1781956222)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/902513/polemik-jabatan-sipil-di-uu-polri-pengamat-sarankan-penolak-ajukan-gugatan-ke-mk), translated from Indonesian
Print