Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

PMHU Number 2 of 2026: Between Pilgrim Protection and Business Fairness

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Regulation
PMHU Number 2 of 2026: Between Pilgrim Protection and Business Fairness
Image: Republika

Minister of Hajj and Umrah Regulation (PMHU) Number 2 of 2026 needs to be placed within the framework of legal philosophy, particularly in relation to the principle of business fairness in the provision of hajj and umrah services. Regulations governing business activities in sectors that intersect with religious interests and public services should not be assessed solely from the aspects of administrative authority and normative compliance, but also from the extent to which the law is able to create a balance between the interests of the state, business actors, and the public as service users.

From the perspective of Aristotle’s distributive justice, the law should provide proportional treatment to every legal subject based on their rights, obligations, and contributions. Meanwhile, from the perspective of John Rawls’ justice as fairness, state regulation must guarantee fair equality of opportunity and must not create disproportionate barriers for certain business actors.

PMHU Number 2 of 2026 must be tested not only based on regulatory objectives and administrative order, but also based on a philosophical question: whether the requirements, restrictions, and licensing mechanisms established have created a reasonable level playing field for all business actors.

The perspective of Pancasila legal philosophy further emphasises that business fairness cannot be separated from the principle of social justice for all Indonesian people as contained in the fifth principle of Pancasila. The state has legitimacy to regulate in order to guarantee service quality, pilgrim protection, legal certainty, and the prevention of business practices that harm the public.

However, this regulatory authority must be exercised proportionally, transparently, rationally, and must not turn into an instrument that creates discrimination or market entry barriers without a legitimate legal basis and purpose. PMHU Number 2 of 2026 philosophically needs to be examined through the balance between legal certainty and justice, including the principles of equality before the law, fairness, proportionality, and protection of the freedom to do business.

A just law is not a law that merely restricts, but a law that is able to regulate competition fairly, prevent domination or monopoly, and ensure that every business actor obtains a proportional opportunity to develop within the hajj and umrah service ecosystem.

In legal philosophy, the authority of the ruler is a trust, not absolute power. The principle of ‘lā ṭā’ata li makhlūqin fī ma’ṣiyat al-Khāliq’ and the rule of ‘taṣarruf al-imām ’alā al-ra’iyyah manūṭun bi al-maṣlaḥah’ affirm that the actions of the ruler must be oriented towards the welfare of the people and remain within the limits of their authority.

Therefore, if PMHU Number 2 of 2026 establishes new requirements that substantively restrict business access without adequate delegation from a law or government regulation, the issue is not only ultra vires in positive law, but also potentially an abuse of the trust of power. Technical standards may be established to safeguard the welfare of pilgrims, but they must not become an instrument to create business restrictions that exceed the legal mandate. Judicial review to the Supreme Court can be seen as a modern hisbah mechanism to restore the use of power to the principles of trust, justice, and public welfare.

The principle of proportionality positions pilgrim protection as an objective aligned with maqāṣid al-sharī’ah, particularly the protection of religion, life, property, and human welfare. However, welfare must not be understood unilaterally. The requirement of three years of experience or 1,000 pilgrims must be tested as to whether it is truly necessary to achieve such protection or whether it instead creates new harm in the form of closed business opportunities, increased compliance costs, and reduced choices for pilgrims.

More from 20 August 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/pmhu-number-2-of-2026-between-pilgrim-protection-and-business-fairness-1787212363)
Originally published by Republika (https://analisis.republika.co.id/berita/tk22vg368/pmhu-nomor-2-tahun-2026-antara-perlindungan-jemaah-dan-keadilan-berusaha), translated from Indonesian
Print