Plain Packaging Plan for Cigarettes Said to Complicate Illegal Tobacco Monitoring
The Ministry of Health’s plan to enforce standardised packaging for tobacco products, as part of the implementation of Government Regulation No. 28/2024, has drawn significant criticism. The provision is seen as potentially eliminating product identity, facilitating counterfeiting, and encouraging the proliferation of illegal cigarettes.
Misbakhun, Chair of Commission XI of the Indonesian House of Representatives (DPR RI), assessed that plain packaging could lead to a massive influx of illegal or foreign cigarette producers into the market, causing the domestic cigarette industry to lose competitiveness. He cited Australia as an example, where state revenue dropped drastically as official cigarette producers lost out to the dominance of illegal cigarettes, resulting in state losses of up to AU$1.6 billion per year. “It was the same in Australia. The state losses were quite large. New Zealand also,” Misbakhun explained.
He stressed that the plain packaging policy is not solely about improving public health, but its impact on the cigarette industry and its derivatives, including the fate of tobacco farmers, must also be scrutinised. “This shows that the cigarette ecosystem is not merely a health matter,” he said.
Beyond the risk of increasing illegal cigarette circulation, which erodes state revenue from excise tax, the Ministry of Industry also voiced concerns. Merriyanti Punguan Pintaria, Director of Beverage, Tobacco Products and Refreshing Materials at the Ministry of Industry, noted that the circulation of illegal cigarettes in Indonesia is already a serious challenge. She highlighted that illegal cigarettes do not contribute excise tax, which is a source of funding for health programmes.
Meanwhile, Dina Kurniasari, Director of WTO Negotiations at the Ministry of Trade, asserted that if the rule proceeds, monitoring the circulation of illegal cigarettes will become a major challenge. She warned that uniform packaging would make it difficult for consumers and authorities to differentiate between legal and counterfeit products, potentially triggering a shift towards cheaper, illegal cigarettes and causing further state losses. Dina urged regulators to conduct a Regulatory Impact Assessment (RIA) before the policy is enacted to understand its full trade implications.
In addition to the plain packaging plan, the tobacco industry is also facing other control policies, including limits on tar and nicotine content and a ban on additives in tobacco products. Critics argue that if these regulations are implemented simultaneously, they will eliminate any distinguishing features between products, leading to mass layoffs in the labour-intensive sector and a significant loss of state revenue from excise.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/plain-packaging-plan-for-cigarettes-said-to-complicate-illegal-tobacco-monitoring-1785203466)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/news/20260727160350-4-754192/rancangan-penyeragaman-kemasan-rokok-persulit-pengawasan-rokok-ilegal), translated from Indonesian