PKS’s Mardani Also Does Not Recall DPR Discussing the ‘Very Gibran’ Provision in KPU Regulation
Mardani Ali Sera, a member of the DPR’s Commission II from the Prosperous Justice Party (PKS) for the 2019–2024 term, said he did not recall any discussion of Article 18(3) of General Elections Commission (KPU) Regulation No. 19 of 2023 on the Nomination of Presidential and Vice-Presidential Election Candidates at a Commission II meeting.
The article states that proof of graduation is not required for a candidate who does not have evidence of graduating from a senior high school overseas but has proof of having graduated from a university. Denny Indrayana and his fellow petitioners have called it the “Very Gibran” article.
The provision reads: “The proof of graduation referred to in paragraph (1), point m, is not required for a presidential or vice-presidential candidate who does not have proof of graduating from a senior high school at a foreign school overseas and has proof of graduating from a university.”
“First, I really don’t remember any discussion of that article,” Mardani said when contacted on Friday (9 October).
Mardani said he was concerned that the provision might never have been discussed at a meeting between the KPU and Commission II. He said he would remember if it had been discussed.
“I’m rather concerned that it seems there was no discussion of it. I would definitely remember if there had been a lengthy discussion,” he said.
Mardani, who is currently also a member of Commission II, said the commission should summon the KPU to explain the provision. He said that if an intention to insert the provision improperly were proven, KPU commissioners could be reported to the Election Organisers’ Ethics Council (DKPP).
“If there was indeed mens rea, then this would be a serious violation and could be brought before the DKPP,” Mardani said.
Ahmad Doli Kurnia, who chaired Commission II during the 2019–2024 term, had also said that Article 18(3) was not included in the PKPU during the commission’s meeting with the KPU.
“So, as far as I know, that paragraph was not there. But, once again, I’m checking with various people, including colleagues in the secretariat, because what we discussed at the time was solely the amendment concerning the Constitutional Court,” he said.
Bambang Widjojanto, a lawyer for Denny Indrayana and the other petitioners, had previously criticised Article 18(3) of KPU Regulation No. 19 of 2023 on the Nomination of Presidential and Vice-Presidential Election Candidates.
He made the criticism after the Constitutional Court (MK) ruled inadmissible a petition challenging the validity of Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s educational qualifications when he stood in the 2024 presidential election.
Bambang said the provision was specifically intended for Gibran’s bid to become vice-president in the 2024 election. In his view, the KPU drafted it to enable Gibran to qualify as a vice-presidential candidate.
“One point of criticism that needs to be brought before the Constitutional Court is Article 18(3). It is very much the Gibran article, and that ‘Very Gibran’ article was passed by the General Elections Commission,” Bambang said at the MK on Tuesday (6 October).
Bambang said the MK’s ruling concerning Gibran’s senior high-school certificate showed that the KPU had breached election principles and rules. He said the KPU should also face sanctions for those breaches.
The KPU’s explanation
KPU member Idham Holik, meanwhile, said the draft wording of Article 18(3) had been discussed at a consolidation meeting on 19 September 2023, a day before a hearing with Commission II on 20 September 2023.
“The draft provision was already in the draft PKPU discussed at the consolidation meeting on 19 September 2023. That meeting took place before the hearing with Commission II on 20 September 2023,” Idham said when contacted on Friday (9 October).
He said the wording had also been formulated following consultations with authorised officials at the relevant ministries.
“So, as a matter of documentary fact, the draft provision already existed,” he said.
Idham added that the draft provision was initially listed as Article 19(2). Following a harmonisation meeting, it was changed to Article 18(3).
“At the consolidation meeting, the draft provision was Article 19(2), and following the harmonisation meeting it became Article 18(3),” he said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/pkss-mardani-also-does-not-recall-dpr-discussing-the-very-gibran-provision-in-kpu-regulation-1791539650)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261009153407-32-1413591/mardani-pks-juga-tak-ingat-pasal-gibran-banget-di-pkpu-dibahas-dpr), translated from Indonesian