Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

PKB Weighs Right to Express an Opinion over Gibran Controversy

| Source: detikcom Translated from Indonesian | Politics
PKB Weighs Right to Express an Opinion over Gibran Controversy
Image: detikcom

The National Awakening Party (PKB) is considering using the Right to Express an Opinion (HMP) over the controversy following Constitutional Court (MK) and Supreme Court (MA) rulings concerning Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s diploma. Muhammad Khozin, head of the PKB faction’s working group on Commission II of the House of Representatives, said HMP would be the ideal course of action.

“In a state governed by the rule of law, what must take precedence is not political calculation, but legal certainty and constitutional accountability. For that reason, PKB is carefully considering the use of the Right to Express an Opinion,” Khozin said in a statement on Monday (9 November 2026).

Khozin said PKB was selecting the most appropriate constitutional route. He said the Right of Inquiry was only intended to examine government policy.

“Meanwhile, HMP is an instrument for the House to express an opinion on constitutional matters. The two are not mutually exclusive and need not be pursued in a particular order,” he said.

Khozin said Article 210(2)(c) of Law No. 17/2014 on the People’s Consultative Assembly, House of Representatives, Regional Representative Council and Regional Legislative Councils—which explicitly refers to valid material and evidence concerning an alleged failure to meet the requirements for serving as president or vice-president—provided a basis for submitting an HMP motion. He said the MK and MA rulings had triggered constitutional debate over the validity of the requirements for holding office.

“The question is whether this diploma issue falls under ‘never having met the nomination requirements’ or ‘no longer meeting the requirements while in office’, as set out in Article 7A(1) of the 1945 Constitution,” he said.

Khozin added that the distinction was important to the constitutional arguments the House must examine. In his view, the House should provide political certainty following rulings by the two judicial institutions.

“The House’s arguments will later be tested by the Constitutional Court when it submits a request to propose the dismissal of the president and/or vice-president. This is why HMP is important in bringing this controversy to an end. The Constitutional Court will provide legal certainty, while parliament will provide political certainty,” he said.

Earlier, Golkar deputy chairman Ahmad Doli Kurnia proposed that the House use its Right to Express an Opinion in connection with the possibility of impeaching Gibran. He said the House’s two other rights were not relevant to the controversy.

“That is why I have said from the outset that the relevant right for the House to use in relation to the Constitutional Court ruling—and now that there is also a Supreme Court ruling—is the Right to Express an Opinion,” Doli said at the parliamentary complex in Senayan, Jakarta, on Monday (9 November).

The Commission II member said he had been in contact with other party factions in the House about the controversy. He said those discussions were taking account of public sentiment.

“I have been contacted by several colleagues from other factions. We have spoken, and we may follow up on those discussions today. The point is that, based on the conversations so far, we are paying close attention to public opinion,” he said.

“Perhaps over the next day or two we will continue the discussions we have been having. Hopefully, we will reach a conclusion at that meeting,” he added.

More from 10 November 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/pkb-weighs-right-to-express-an-opinion-over-gibran-controversy-1794282739)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8746131/pkb-pertimbangkan-hak-menyatakan-pendapat-terkait-polemik-gibran), translated from Indonesian
Print