PKB Pushes for Special Committee on Gibran’s Diploma; Golkar Says Summoning the Election Commission Is Enough
The follow-up to the Constitutional Court’s ruling on the validity of Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s candidacy requirements in the 2024 presidential election has now reached the House of Representatives (DPR).
Several political parties in the parliamentary coalition supporting the Prabowo Subianto-Gibran government have responded to the ruling. In its legal reasoning, the Constitutional Court said it had not found documents showing that the Vice-President held a diploma proving completion of overseas education equivalent to senior secondary school, as required to register for the 2024 election.
One response came from Eka Widodo, a member of the DPR’s Commission II from the National Awakening Party (PKB), who proposed forming a special committee to follow up on the ruling.
Widodo, commonly known as Edo, said the Court’s reasoning should be considered by state institutions with constitutional authority to ensure that presidential and vice-presidential requirements are met.
He stressed that the issue should not be seen as an attempt to disregard or reopen the Constitutional Court’s ruling. Instead, he said, the DPR should respect the decision while carrying out its constitutional duties if there are sufficient grounds and evidence to follow up on the matter.
“The Constitutional Court’s ruling must be respected. But the Court’s reasoning must also be read in full. If there are factual matters that still need to be established, the state institutions with the relevant authority must conduct verification objectively, transparently and on the basis of evidence,” Edo said in a written statement on Thursday (8 October).
Edo noted that the 1945 Constitution provides a mechanism for cases in which a president or vice-president no longer meets the required qualifications.
He said Article 7A of the 1945 Constitution provides for the possible removal of the President and/or Vice-President if they are proven to have committed certain violations or no longer meet the requirements for office.
Article 7B sets out the removal process, including the DPR’s ability to express an opinion and the Constitutional Court’s authority to examine, hear and decide on that opinion before the process continues in the People’s Consultative Assembly (MPR).
Special committee
Edo said that if strong evidence emerged and a constitutional issue required follow-up, the DPR had oversight instruments and could use mechanisms provided for in the Constitution.
“One option, if considered necessary, would be to establish a special committee to conduct a comprehensive investigation,” he said.
He said that if a committee were formed, its primary task would not be to pass judgement or take over the authority of other institutions, but to clarify and establish the facts objectively.
Edo said that if the DPR’s oversight and investigation found sufficient evidence of a constitutional issue concerning the vice-presidential eligibility requirements, the House could use the mechanism set out in Article 7B of the 1945 Constitution.
“If a special committee is established, it must work to establish the facts: whether the educational documents used to meet the requirements actually exist, how their equivalency was assessed, who conducted the verification, and whether all the procedures complied with the law. Everything must be proven, not based on assumptions,” he said.
PKB is led by its chairman, Muhaimin Iskandar. Although the party was once an electoral rival of Prabowo-Gibran in the 2024 presidential election, Muhaimin eventually brought PKB into the governing coalition. He and several PKB cadres joined the Cabinet; Muhaimin became Coordinating Minister for Community Empowerment.
Summon election administrators
In contrast to Edo, Ahmad Doli Kurnia, a member of Commission II from the Golkar Party, said there was no need for a special committee, an inquiry or any other form of investigation in this case.
He said Commission II only needed to summon the election administrators—the General Elections Commission (KPU) and the Election Supervisory Agency (Bawaslu)—to follow up on the issue of Gibran’s diploma.
“Commission II should summon the election administrators and ask how the nomination process took place, given that the Constitutional Court has now established that the diploma was not there. The KPU, Bawaslu and the others should explain,” Doli said.
Doli also said a special committee or parliamentary inquiry was unnecessary in relation to calls for Gibran’s removal from office.
He added that any discussion of removal would depend on decisions made by the political parties, since the matter had entered the political sphere.
“As for removal, that depends on agreement and consensus among the political party leaders, particularly those in the DPR. This is now entirely a political matter,” he said.
Golkar was a supporter of the Prabowo-Gibran ticket in the 2024 presidential election. The party is led by Bahlil Lahadalia, who is now Coordinating Minister for Downstreaming and Energy Transition. He previously served as Energy and Mineral Resources Minister.
The Constitutional Court previously issued a ruling on a case challenging the validity of Gibran’s educational qualifications for the 2024 presidential election.
At the hearing, one of the petitioners, Denny Indrayana, said the document used to support Gibran’s nomination was only an equivalency letter issued by the Ministry of Education, rather than proof of graduation or a diploma.
The Court ruled that it could not accept the petition because the petitioners lacked legal standing.
However, attention focused on the Court’s statement that it had not found documents showing that Gibran held a diploma proving completion of overseas education equivalent to senior secondary school.
In reasoning read out by Constitutional Court Justice Adies Kadir, the Court said that although it had not found convincing evidence of Gibran’s diploma for the 2024 candidacy requirements, he was no longer a vice-presidential candidate in fact.
The Court also said the question of the missing evidence of a diploma equivalent to senior secondary education fell within the remit of other institutions with authority under the 1945 Constitution.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/pkb-pushes-for-special-committee-on-gibrans-diploma-golkar-says-summoning-the-election-commission-is-enough-1791507180)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261009061104-32-1413350/pkb-dorong-pansus-ijazah-gibran-golkar-sebut-hanya-cukup-panggil-kpu), translated from Indonesian