Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Pigai Urges Experts to Remain Objective in Assessing Government Policies

| Source: Antara (Indonesian) Translated from Indonesian | Politics
Pigai Urges Experts to Remain Objective in Assessing Government Policies
Image: Antara (Indonesian)

Jakarta (ANTARA) - Human Rights Minister Natalius Pigai has requested that experts assess government policies objectively, critiquing deficiencies without ignoring the achievements or benefits of programmes for the public.

Speaking in Jakarta on Tuesday, Pigai stated that criticism of government policy remains necessary if there are flaws in its implementation. However, he noted that assessments should also include the successes or benefits of policies so that the public receives a complete picture.

“Therefore, experts should not negate the government’s good deeds. They must also acknowledge the government’s successes. If there are management shortcomings, they should be criticised; that is fine,” said Pigai.

He added that criticism regarding policy deficiencies can still be voiced, even to the point of demanding accountability from officials, without disregarding the achievements that benefit the community.

These remarks were made in response to Mahfud MD’s reaction to President Prabowo Subianto’s comments regarding certain experts during a speech at the 28th anniversary of the National Mandate Party (PAN).

In a speech in Jakarta on Friday (18/9), Prabowo claimed that some experts had been spreading slander and emphasised the importance of intellectual honesty. During the occasion, Prabowo notably used the expression “so smart that they become stupid.”

Responding to Prabowo’s statement, Mahfud MD remarked that there are indeed experts and professors who, in his view, do not meet the required standards of expertise. However, he also noted that the President and other officials could possess similar shortcomings.

Pigai subsequently stated that the President’s criticism should not be understood as a generalisation of all experts. He linked the parties referred to by the President to groups that he believes operate within a ‘post-truth’ pattern.

“This is merely ‘post-truth’ as Mr Prabowo mentioned. It does not apply to everyone. ‘Post-truth’ refers to those who collectively silence the truth, those who collectively kill the truth, and those who refuse to acknowledge the truth but instead create or propagate falsehoods,” said Pigai.

According to Pigai, the group he is referring to consists of parties that negate the truth and construct alternative narratives.

Pigai also assessed that expertise must be distinguished from partisan activities or an individual’s involvement in political debates. He argued that the statements of an expert can influence both policy and the public, meaning expertise must be accompanied by objective assessment.

“That is why we are pointing out the groups that silence the truth,” Pigai concluded.

More from 22 September 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/pigai-urges-experts-to-remain-objective-in-assessing-government-policies-1790078389)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5753125/pigai-minta-pakar-tetap-objektif-menilai-kebijakan-pemerintah), translated from Indonesian
Print