Pigai: Prabowo's Criticism of 'Experts' Does Not Apply to All Scientists
The Minister for Human Rights, Natalius Pigai, has explained that President Prabowo Subianto’s criticism regarding the phenomenon of ‘experts’ is not directed at all scientists or specialists.
“What the President means are groups that hold multiple overlapping roles. Intellectual groups and experts who also act as activists, buzzers, influencers, haters, supporters of Party A or Party B, or members of interest groups,” Pigai stated during a press conference in Jakarta on Tuesday.
Pigai noted that this phenomenon is visible on social media, where individuals with specific academic backgrounds are labelled as experts while simultaneously acting as partisans, influencers, or supporters of particular political factions.
He argued that such individuals must be distinguished from scientists or specialists who present views based on their academic capacity. Pigai emphasised that the President’s statement was not intended to generalise all scientists or experts.
“So, it is not everyone. As I mentioned, there are those who are called professors or doctors in constitutional law, but they were previously ministers, then members of the House of Representatives for a political party, then leaders of high state institutions, then activists, then candidates for national leadership, and now social media managers,” he said.
“What the President is criticising are ‘post-truth experts’ who silence and bury the truth. Post-truth experts,” Pigai added.
He noted that the development of social media and the internet allows information and opinions to circulate widely. Therefore, an individual’s capacity and position as a source of information must be understood proportionally.
“Please understand that what the President conveyed does not apply to everyone. It is not everyone. But these specific ‘experts’ operate in that manner,” he said.
Pigai also provided historical examples regarding debates on science and public policy to illustrate the risks when what he termed ‘misleading information’ influences decision-making.
According to Pigai, criticism of this phenomenon should not be interpreted as a rejection of science or expertise. He stated that the government still requires input from scientists and experts in the formulation of policy.
“There is a difference between a scientist and an ‘expert’ [in this context]. The President praises and respects scientists. Those who advise the President are all scientists,” Pigai concluded.
He added that the public needs to distinguish between views based on expertise and opinions influenced by specific interests to ensure that public discourse remains grounded in accountable information.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/pigai-prabowos-criticism-of-experts-does-not-apply-to-all-scientists-1790075199)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5752993/pigai-kritik-prabowo-soal-pakar-bukan-untuk-semua-ilmuwan), translated from Indonesian