Pigai: Blocking of Student Protest March to Hotel Indonesia Roundabout Complies with Regulations
Human Rights Minister Nataliaks Pigai has stated that the interception carried out by joint TNI-Polri security forces against students during the ‘Towards a Bankrupt Indonesia’ demonstration was in accordance with applicable regulations.
He explained that the blocking, intended to prevent students from demonstrating in the Bundaran Hotel Indonesia (HI) area, aligns with Jakarta Governor Regulation Number 232 of 2015 regarding the Control of Public Expression in Open Spaces.
“Regarding demonstrations in business and high-traffic areas, there are established rules. No violations were committed by the relevant authorities regarding the interception,” Pigai said at the DPR, MPR, and DPD Complex on Wednesday, 17 June 2026.
He emphasised that while he supports students exercising their right to public expression, it is important to recognise that authorities are permitted to implement certain restrictions.
According to Pigai, within the context of human rights, the Siracusa Principles grant authorities the power to impose limitations for specific reasons, such as the Bundaran Hotel Indonesia area being a business and traffic epicentre.
Under these principles, both demonstrators and duty officers have a responsibility to respect other civil rights, including public order. “Therefore, it is consistent with the Siracusa human rights principles that demonstrations cannot take place at this specific point, but can occur elsewhere, considering traffic congestion or other strategic factors. However, I appreciate the students for continuously voicing the rights of the people,” said the former National Commission on Human Rights Commissioner.
The Siracusa Principles regulate the limitation and derogation of human rights within the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. These principles are used to limit freedom of expression to prevent the incitement of war, the spread of hatred, discrimination based on religion, ethnicity, or race, and threats to national order.
In practice, the Siracusa Principles stipulate that restrictions on civil and political rights must not be discriminatory and must be implemented based on urgent social needs for legitimate purposes, such as protecting national security, public safety, public order, health, public morals, and the rights and freedoms of others.
Students participating in the ‘Towards a Bankrupt Indonesia’ action were intercepted by joint TNI-Polri forces as they attempted to reach the demonstration site at the Bundaran Hotel Indonesia area.
Yatalathof Ma’shum Imawan, Chairman of the University of Indonesia Student Executive Board (BEM) who participated in the protest, stated that the interception by authorities began when the crowd arrived in the Semanggi area and continued in front of the Thamrin Nine Building.
The Head of Public Relations for the Jakarta Metropolitan Regional Police, Commissioner Budi Hermanto, explained the reason why police denied students access to the Bundaran Hotel Indonesia area.
He stated that, as per Jakarta Governor Regulation Number 232 of 2015, the Bundaran Hotel Indonesia area is not permitted to be used as a demonstration site.
He noted that areas ranging from Bundaran Senayan, Semanggi, and Bundaran Hotel Indonesia to the Arjuna Wijaya Horse Statue in Central Jakarta are business and traffic epicentres; therefore, demonstrations would result in significant traffic congestion. “If these main roads in Jakarta are paralysed, other public activities will be disrupted. This is what we must communicate to the public and the students,” Budi said at the Bundaran Hotel Indonesia area.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/pigai-blocking-of-student-protest-march-to-hotel-indonesia-roundabout-complies-with-regulations-1781708037)
Originally published by Tempo (Indonesian) (https://nasional.tempo.co/read/2109020/pigai-pengadangan-demo-mahasiswa-menuju-hi-sesuai-aturan), translated from Indonesian