Personal Attacks on Social Media Deemed Unrepresentative of Public Opinion
The proliferation of content on social media attacking the personal character of the head of government is considered not to reflect the quality of a healthy democracy. Criticism of the government should be directed at policies and performance, rather than turning into insults that target the personal sphere.
Political observer and Executive Director of Indeks Data Nasional, Ayip Tayana, judged that labelling the head of government with Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD) does not constitute substantive criticism.
“This nation must be able to distinguish between criticism and what is called insult. The government must indeed be criticised, but in my view calling it NPD is not criticism,” Ayip said.
According to him, personal attacks that degrade a person’s dignity cannot be justified in the name of freedom of expression. Criticism should be accompanied by argumentation and directed at government policies or actions.
“There is no argumentation there, no accountability. It is used solely to inflame public emotion and anger,” he said.
Ayip noted that negative-toned content often receives high engagement on social media. This situation could create the mistaken assumption that conversations on social media represent the views of the majority of society.
“In Indonesia, content with a negative or emotional tone that attacks certain political groups tends to receive high engagement. Let us not allow such things to drag on, because democracy requires freedom of speech, but also maturity and responsibility,” he said.
He assessed that the high volume of negative conversations on social media does not automatically depict public attitudes as a whole. In terms of political legitimacy as well as various survey results, he said, the level of support for the government remains in the majority.
Ayip said the government obtained strong political legitimacy through a general election won in a single round with around 58 percent of the vote.
In addition, he cited the results of a Poltracking Indonesia survey showing that 74.2 percent of respondents expressed trust in the government, while 72.2 percent stated they were satisfied with the government’s performance.
“These various survey results can be an indicator that public support for and trust in the government remain at a majority level,” he said.
Nevertheless, Ayip reminded that high levels of public satisfaction do not mean all government policies have been accepted without criticism. Findings of dissatisfaction in certain sectors still need to be used as material for evaluation.
“The high satisfaction figures deserve appreciation, but findings of dissatisfaction in certain sectors must also serve as material for the government’s evaluation,” he said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/personal-attacks-on-social-media-deemed-unrepresentative-of-public-opinion-1784476273)
Originally published by Republika (https://news.republika.co.id/berita/tifg3d522/serangan-personal-di-media-sosial-dinilai-tak-mewakili-pandangan-publik), translated from Indonesian