Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Perludem Highlights Political Calculations Stalling Election Law Revision

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Politics
Perludem Highlights Political Calculations Stalling Election Law Revision
Image: Media Indonesia

The discussion on revising the Election Law (RUU Pemilu) continues to drag on because lawmakers are more focused on issues directly related to the electoral interests of political parties than on resolving fundamental problems in election administration. Khoirunnisa Nur Agustyati, an election expert and member of the Board of Trustees of the Association for Elections and Democracy (Perludem), reminded that the revision of the Election Law should be completed soon, as the terms of the General Elections Commission (KPU) and the Election Supervisory Body (Bawaslu) commissioners will end this October. “The law has not been revised. We must not end up recruiting using the old law while the election uses the new law. That would be out of sync,” Nisa said during a public discussion in Jakarta on Wednesday (17/6).

According to her, experience in overseeing the revision of the Election Law and the Regional Election Law shows that discussions in the House of Representatives (DPR) and the government often focus on electoral system issues, such as the open or closed list proportional representation model, the size of the parliamentary threshold, and the magnitude of electoral districts. “The attention of lawmakers is absorbed by system issues, open or closed lists, whether the parliamentary threshold goes up or down, whether districts are large or small. Meanwhile, issues like political parties, money politics, identity politics, and electoral technology challenges such as AI are not being discussed optimally,” she said.

Nisa assessed that this situation is inseparable from the interests of political parties, which view electoral regulations as a crucial instrument in determining their chances of winning parliamentary seats. “I understand that for political parties, the election law is a matter of life and death. They have certainly run simulations. If variable A is chosen, they get a certain number of seats; if variable B is chosen, their seats decrease,” she said. As a result, she sees that the closer the discussion gets to the 2029 election, the more pragmatic the revision process will become, while various fundamental problems remain unaddressed.

In addition to highlighting the substance of the revision, Nisa also revealed several issues arising from the simultaneous implementation of the 2024 General Election and Regional Elections. She said that the entire election stages taking place in a single year placed an extremely heavy burden on political parties and election organisers. “Political parties are not forced to carry out continuous political recruitment because elections are only held once every five years. Consequently, they often seek popular figures or those with money because all candidate needs pile up in one year,” she explained. She added that election organisers also face overlapping stages between the general election and regional elections, making the workload increasingly complex.

On the other hand, Nisa believes that budget efficiency is still possible in election administration, for example through the implementation of electronic recapitulation, which has been initiated by the KPU. “The KPU has initiated electronic recapitulation. This can significantly save costs. With simultaneous elections, honorariums for officers are also paid in a single event, making administration more efficient,” she said. However, she noted that the biggest challenge lies in political costs, which are difficult to measure and monitor. “The problem is that these political costs are opaque. There are nomination costs, campaign costs, and even regional head candidates who admit to spending tens to hundreds of billions of rupiah. But when checked in the campaign finance reports submitted to the KPU, the figures do not appear that large,” she said. Nisa stressed that political financing reform and strengthening law enforcement must be an important part of the Election Law revision to curb money politics practices and improve the quality of democracy.

More from 17 June 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/perludem-highlights-political-calculations-stalling-election-law-revision-1781689873)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/901415/ruu-pemilu-tak-kunjung-dibahas-perludem-soroti-parpol-tersandera-hitung-hitungan-politik), translated from Indonesian
Print