PBB: Do not let voters’ voices be wasted because of the parliamentary threshold
Jakarta (ANTARA) – Acting chairman of the Crescent Star Party’s (PBB) central executive board, Yuri Kemal Fadlullah, stressed that voters’ voices must not be lost because of the parliamentary threshold.
“For the Crescent Star Party, every vote cast by the public has constitutional value and must be respected. Votes legitimately cast in an election must not lose their representative significance solely because the parliamentary threshold is applied too rigidly,” Yuri said in a statement in Jakarta on Tuesday.
Yuri made the remarks after PBB, the United Development Party (PPP) and Partai Elang formally petitioned the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Indonesia on Monday (19 October) to conduct a substantive review of several provisions in Law No. 7 of 2017 on General Elections, as most recently amended by Law No. 1 of 2026.
The petition challenges two provisions: Article 173(3), concerning the verification of political parties taking part in elections, and Article 415(1), concerning the calculation of House of Representatives (DPR) seats in connection with the parliamentary threshold.
Yuri said the legal action was a constitutional effort to pursue a fairer, more proportional electoral system that respects popular sovereignty.
PBB and the other petitioning parties are asking the Constitutional Court to give a constitutional interpretation of Article 415(1) of the Elections Law that would allow political parties to combine for the purpose of calculating DPR seats.
Under such a mechanism, parties that individually fail to meet the national threshold could join a party that has met it, or combine with one or more other parties that collectively meet the national threshold.
“We are not asking for the parliamentary threshold to be abolished. What we are seeking is a constitutional mechanism that allows voters’ voices to continue to count through the combination of political parties. This would enable the goal of simplifying the party system to be pursued without sacrificing the principle of representation,” Yuri said.
He said the proposed mechanism could also serve as a compromise between the need for an effective party system and the state’s obligation to ensure that votes have equal value in elections.
In addition to the parliamentary threshold, PBB, PPP and Partai Elang are challenging Article 173(3) of the Elections Law, which they argue creates legal uncertainty and treats parties that have previously contested elections disproportionately.
Yuri said parties with experience in the two most recent election cycles should be treated in a way that takes their status and participation record into account, unlike parties that have never been designated as election participants.
He said certainty over the verification process was essential to ensure that all political parties had a fair opportunity and could prepare in a measured way for the 2029 election.
“The state must provide consistent legal certainty to all election participants. Rules that keep changing or give rise to differing interpretations risk undermining fairness and equality in democratic competition,” Yuri said.
He said the electoral system should balance the need for effective government and a simpler party system with respect for the public’s political choices.
“Democracy must not end with the voting process. It must also ensure that the people’s voices receive proper respect in the formation of representative institutions. That is the spirit we are bringing to the Constitutional Court,” Yuri said.
PBB hopes the Constitutional Court will consider the petition objectively and comprehensively, particularly in relation to popular sovereignty, equality before the law, equal opportunities in government, and the conduct of free and fair elections as guaranteed by the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia.
Yuri also stressed that the move was part of PBB’s commitment to continue contributing to improvements in the national political and democratic system through constitutional channels.
“We respect the authority and independence of the Constitutional Court. Our hope is simple: that Indonesia’s electoral system becomes fairer, provides legal certainty for political parties and, most importantly, does not waste voters’ voices,” he said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/pbb-do-not-let-voters-voices-be-wasted-because-of-the-parliamentary-threshold-1792507974)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5800237/pbb-jangan-biarkan-suara-rakyat-terbuang-akibat-ambang-batas-parlemen), translated from Indonesian