Patents or Trade Secrets: A Strategic Choice in Business Development
Innovation-based businesses do not always need to register every piece of technology or business information through a patent. In certain circumstances, keeping information confidential can serve as a more appropriate intellectual property protection strategy.
Therefore, entrepreneurs need to consider the characteristics of their innovation before choosing between a patent and a trade secret. This choice determines how the innovation is protected and how much information is disclosed to the public.
The Director General of Intellectual Property, Hermansyah Siregar, explained that these two forms of protection are fundamentally different. A patented invention will eventually be published to the public, whereas trade secrets rely on the confidentiality of the information.
“Trade secret protection is not obtained through registration like patents or trademarks. Protection arises automatically as long as the owner is able to maintain the confidentiality of that information,” he stated in a written statement on Tuesday (2/30).
According to him, companies need to implement security measures to ensure that protection remains valid. These steps include non-disclosure agreements (NDAs), restricting data access, and maintaining adequate information security systems.
Business confidentiality is protected under the trade secret regime regulated by Law Number 30 of 2000 concerning Trade Secrets. This protection is relevant for entrepreneurs, researchers, startups, and industries seeking to maintain a competitive advantage against misuse by third parties.
Articles 1 and 2 of the law regulate the scope of protection. This includes production methods, processing methods, sales methods, or other information in the fields of technology and/or business that holds economic value and is not known to the general public.
Examples include food and beverage recipes, product formulas, business algorithms, marketing strategies, customer data, and specific manufacturing processes.
The Director of Patents, Integrated Circuit Layout Designs, and Trade Secrets at DJKI, Andrieansjah, noted that many business actors do not yet understand this potential. He described trade secrets as an intellectual property instrument for information that is not publicly known, possesses economic value, and is maintained by its owner.
“Many business actors are not yet aware that product formulas, marketing strategies, and certain production methods can become high-value intellectual property assets,” he added.
Andrieansjah emphasised that there are three main requirements for information to be protected as a trade secret. First, the information must not be known to the public. Second, the information must have economic value as it can be used for business activities or to increase profits. Third, the owner must have taken reasonable steps to maintain its secrecy.
Thus, business owners must ensure that the information they wish to protect is truly treated as a secret. As long as these three requirements are met, the information can obtain trade secret protection.
DJKI also warned that trade secret violations can occur under several conditions, such as when someone intentionally discloses secret information, breaches a duty of confidentiality, or obtains information through methods that contravene laws and regulations.
Owners of trade secrets have the right to use the information themselves or grant licences to other parties. They also have the right to prohibit others from disclosing it for commercial purposes.
With this right, confidentiality does not diminish the economic value of information. In fact, confidentiality can be part of a business strategy as long as the information continues to meet the criteria for protection.
Hermansyah added that trade secret protection is a vital part of building a healthy and competitive national innovation ecosystem.
“We invite entrepreneurs, inventors, academics, and the public to recognise the intellectual property assets they possess. By understanding the appropriate protection mechanisms, whether through patents or trade secrets, innovation can provide optimal economic benefits while being protected from misuse by others,” he concluded.
As a protective measure, DJKI encourages the public to identify economically valuable information within their business activities. This information must be guarded through adequate procedures.
DJKI also invites business actors to consult with them if they require assistance in determining the most suitable intellectual property protection strategy for their business needs.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/patents-or-trade-secrets-a-strategic-choice-in-business-development-1790693701)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260929202032-17-1409690/paten-atau-rahasia-dagang-pilihan-strategis-dalam-kembangkan-bisnis), translated from Indonesian