Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Participants’ Rights in the Separation of Insurance Sharia Units

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Regulation
Participants’ Rights in the Separation of Insurance Sharia Units
Image: Republika

JAKARTA — Every house move raises a simple question: who is told, and who is merely carried along? That question is now relevant to the Sharia insurance industry. The deadline of 31 December 2026 marks the end of the period for insurance and reinsurance companies to separate their Sharia units. Financial Services Authority Regulation (POJK) No. 11/2023 provides only two options: establish a new Sharia insurance company, or transfer the entire membership portfolio to an existing licensed Sharia insurance company.

A company that does neither will lose its Sharia unit licence. So far, attention has focused on companies’ readiness in terms of capital, systems and human resources. That is understandable. But one party with a major stake is seldom asked: the participants. They own the tabarru’ fund, they grant the authority to manage it, and their data will also be transferred.

This article begins from one principle: participants’ funds and trust are a responsibility that must not be lost in the transfer. Participants are not luggage; they are owners entitled to be informed, to understand, and to have a genuine choice.

Owners, Not Passengers

In Sharia insurance, participants’ position differs from that of customers in conventional insurance. Two legal relationships must be distinguished. First, the relationship among participants: through the tabarru’ contract, each participant donates part of their contribution to a collective fund to help one another when someone suffers a misfortune. The donation is made to fellow participants, not to the company.

Accordingly, the National Sharia Council of the Indonesian Ulema Council’s (DSN-MUI) Fatwa No. 53/DSN-MUI/III/2006 stipulates that investment returns from the tabarru’ fund belong collectively to the participants. Second, there is the relationship between participants and the company: collectively, participants authorise the company to manage the fund through a wakalah bil ujrah contract (DSN-MUI Fatwa No. 52/DSN-MUI/III/2006). The company is an agent paid for its services, not the owner of the fund. In short, participants contribute to one another; the company merely safeguards the fund.

This is why transferring a portfolio is a matter of fiqh, not merely administration. What changes hands is not just policy documentation, but the trust to manage other people’s property. DSN-MUI Fatwa No. 52/DSN-MUI/III/2006 identifies participants in the tabarru’ account as muwakkil, or principals granting authority; affirms that a wakalah contract is a trust; and stipulates that an agent may not delegate the authority received to another party without the principal’s permission.

The Compilation of Sharia Economic Law, which guides religious court judges, sets out the same principle in Article 471. If permission is granted, the new authorised party becomes the participants’ direct agent. This means that the company receiving the portfolio will ultimately be directly accountable to participants. Trust, it seems, does not transfer automatically.

Safeguards Already in Place

Regulations have, in fact, established safeguards. POJK No. 11/2023 and Financial Services Authority Circular Letter No. 10/SEOJK.05/2024 stipulate that a transfer of the membership portfolio includes the tabarru’ fund, participants’ investment funds, ujrah provisions and any required qardh, and must not reduce policyholders’ and participants’ rights.

No later than 20 working days after the Financial Services Authority (OJK) approves the transfer, the company must notify participants by letter or electronic media and announce it in national mass media and on the company’s website. The announcement must state the period during which participants may object. If a participant refuses, their coverage ends and their entitlements must be returned.

Law No. 27/2022 on Personal Data Protection adds another layer. Article 48 requires a legal entity undertaking a merger, division, acquisition, consolidation or dissolution to notify data subjects of the transfer of their personal data before and after the corporate action. The common thread is clear: both rules rely on notification, rather than the express consent of every participant.

In effect, the rules apply the principle that silence means consent: participants who have been notified and do not object are deemed to accept the transfer. This is practical, and Islamic law can also accommodate it. But one condition must not be overlooked — and it lies precisely in what silence means.

Silence with Meaning

A well-known fiqh maxim states: lā yunsabu ilā sākīti qawl, wa lākinna as-sukūtu fī ma‘riḍ al-ḥājati ilā al-bayāni bayān. Roughly translated: nothing can be attributed as a statement to a person who is silent; but when someone remains silent at a time when they ought to speak, that silence is treated as a statement.

A study published in the Samarah journal by UIN Ar-Raniry on tacit consent in Sharia banking reached the same conclusion: silence alone is not enough to be treated as consent. There must be a clear indication that the customer agrees.

Silence is, by default, an empty space. It only speaks when preceded by knowledge. Whether participants’ silence can validly be interpreted as consent therefore depends on one thing: whether they truly know and understand, and have reasonable time to consider the matter. A notification buried in an email inbox, written in dense legal language and accompanied by a short objection deadline, does not meet that standard.

Herein lies the gap: spin-off rules require companies to state the objection period, but do not set a minimum. In practice this year, one company gave participants only seven calendar days — a short time to consider a decision affecting protection that may last for years.

Participants also need to understand the cost of each option. Objecting means their coverage ends. For life insurance participants who are older or have certain medical histories, finding new protection is not always easy. A choice whose consequences are not understood is not yet a free choice.

More from 26 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/participants-rights-in-the-separation-of-insurance-sharia-units-1792986683)
Originally published by Republika (https://opini.republika.co.id/berita/tnhmrz451/hak-peserta-dalam-pemisahan-unit-syariah-asuransi), translated from Indonesian
Print