PAN Open to Option of Legislative Elections Before Presidential Election, Cites Election Costs
The Deputy Chairperson of Golkar Party, Ahmad Doli Kurnia, has proposed that Legislative Elections (Pileg) be held first, with the results serving as a ‘ticket’ for the Presidential Election (Pilpres). The National Mandate Party (PAN) believes this design requires a comprehensive review.
PAN Deputy Chairperson Viva Yoga Mauladi stated that the Election Bill must be viewed holistically rather than discussed in parts. He noted that any proposed changes to the election design must adhere to the rulings of the Constitutional Court (MK).
“PAN’s principle is that the 2029 election design must be constitutional, follow the Constitutional Court rulings, and maintain the quality of the presidential system,” Viva Yoga told reporters on Thursday (24/9/2026).
“This means the election design must consider the interests of voters, the burden on organisers, election costs, campaign quality, the effectiveness of the presidential government, and, most importantly, the ease for the public to exercise their right to vote,” he added.
Viva noted that the proposal to separate legislative and presidential elections represents a new design option that requires further study by the House of Representatives (DPR) and the government.
“Certainly, PAN views this proposal as differing from Constitutional Court Decision No. 135/PUU-XXII/2024, which separates National Elections (electing members of the DPR RI, DPD RI, and presidential/vice-presidential pairs) and Local Elections (electing provincial and regency/city DPRD members, governors, regents, and mayors) starting in 2029,” he explained.
Viva added that while PAN understands the reasoning behind holding legislative elections first—namely so that the results can serve as a ‘political ticket’—the matter requires further investigation.
Furthermore, Viva highlighted the Constitutional Court’s decision to abolish the presidential threshold. Therefore, any change in election design must ensure it does not create new constitutional issues.
“PAN’s guideline is that we must not resolve one constitutional problem only to create a new one,” he said.
“Therefore, PAN’s position is open to various options, including the idea of legislative elections first, as long as the final design is constitutional, rational, simple, non-discriminatory towards participating parties, and capable of producing a better democratic system,” he continued.
Meanwhile, PAN politician Saleh Partaonan Daulay believes the discourse on holding legislative elections first needs to be simulated. He argued that lawmakers need to weigh the pros and cons of such a design change.
“The articles in the Election Bill are decisive. There are many interests to be accommodated, especially those of the contesting parties,” he said.
“So, is it better to prioritise the legislative election? This is a question that needs simulation. If the argument is merely to secure a ticket for the presidential election, I believe that is insufficient,” he added.
He noted that separating legislative, presidential, and regional elections would require significant funding, as each contest requires its own organisational budget.
“Just check it. If everything is separated, the cost will certainly be high. Meanwhile, one of the reasons for combining them is for efficiency and budget savings,” he explained.
“This does not mean I am proposing they be combined, but I suggest a simulation be conducted first. The pros and cons should be examined. We appreciate Golkar’s proposal, but that proposal must not overlook other essential matters,” he added.
Previously, Ahmad Doli Kurnia stated that legislative, presidential, and regional elections should be held separately. Doli proposed that legislative elections be held first, with the results acting as a nomination ticket for the presidential election.
Doli stated that this proposal has been presented since the early stages of discussions regarding simultaneous elections. He argued that each type of election should have its own implementation period.
“Regarding simultaneous elections, we have proposed from the beginning that the three types of elections we have—legislative, presidential, and regional—should be held separately, without being unified,” Doli told reporters on Tuesday (22/9).
Doli explained that there are several reasons behind this proposal, including allowing the public to focus more clearly on their choices for each type of election.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/pan-open-to-option-of-legislative-elections-before-presidential-election-cites-election-costs-1790258385)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8677879/pan-terbuka-soal-opsi-pileg-dulu-baru-pilres-singgung-biaya-pemilu), translated from Indonesian