PAN likely to dominate June general election
PAN likely to dominate June general election
This is the second of two articles on potential results of the
coming general election prepared by Lance Castles, an Australian
scholar and visiting lecturer of political sciences at Gadjah
Mada University, Yogyakarta.
YOGYAKARTA (JP): Amien Rais of the National Mandate Party
(PAN) is becoming increasingly popular among eligible voters as
we approach the general election on June 7.
They intuitively see that few PAN people will defect between
now and June 7, but the party will receive millions of new
supporters. It is above all Amien's incredibly favorable TV image
that is to thank (or to blame) for this.
Expected winning party percentage breakdowns for the directly
elected part of the House of Representatives (DPR), referred to
in Monday's paper, therefore, have to be recalculated as follows.
Each party obtains one-third of its raw percentage for a positive
avowal, plus another third for a return to first love. The other
third all go to PAN. Distributing proportionately the unused
votes for parties not reaching 2 percent, the result is as shown
in the first sentence above.
Quod erat demonstrandum. I believe I have marshaled facts and
reason as I was taught to do, and will be glad to receive
criticism on the same lines, though not just anecdotes. The
revelation of the Luddite qualities of so many colleagues in
relation to polling has been the greatest shock of my academic
career. The views have swung between denial that polls in
Indonesia have any value and predictions utterly in contradiction
with published data.
One Australian scholar, for instance, recently maintained that
Golkar would obtain 40 percent of the vote. Since it only
receives 7 percent in urban areas, and they comprise 35 percent
of the population, Golkar would have to obtain more than 57
percent of the rural vote, or a multiple of eight compared with
the urban vote, to receive the overall total of 40 percent.
This is absurd on at least two grounds.
First, it assumes that rural voters are dumb automatons living
in terror of village heads and security guards and who are
oblivious of the command posts, Poskos, and party flags flying
over villages. The hypothesis assumes that rural voters are
incapable of grasping what the TV tells them every night, namely
that the polls are secret, that Golkar is to blame for everything
and that Amien is the most promising candidate in the field.
Second, rural-urban differentials, except for special cases
like the rural National Party in Australia, are of a 60/40 rather
than an 8/1 character. Rural voters might give a 55 percent
approval rating to Clinton rather then the 70 percent nation-wide
figure, but they would not give him only 9 percent.
If the Australian Democrats obtain 10 percent of first
preference votes, graduates may contribute an above average
number of these votes, say 20 percent, but not at 8 times the
vote of non-graduates, say 50 percent. Actually, the 1955
election results in Indonesia show no discernible urban-rural
differentials at all. I referred to this general finding as a
psephology discovery, only to have my naive faith in it dismissed
by an American expert. Presumably, for him psephology is only
valid for civilized countries in which he is not an expert.
Anyway, when the results come out there will no doubt be many
surprised people. The thought will occur that when a new paradigm
relevant to a purpose occurs, e.g. predicting voting behavior, it
must be immediately embraced and the old paradigms -- inside
knowledge, long experience, the latest anecdote, etc. -- will
become totally irrelevant. In Indonesia, Amien Rais, Rizal
Panggabean and (in a Detak interview) Sarwono are the only people
I have discovered who know how to predict the outcome on the
basis of poll results.
Recently, I was asked to write an introduction to a book which
contains chapters on eight parties, including their prospects, to
which both party spokesmen and independent commentators made
contributions. Not a single person in either category referred to
poll findings as a source of information, and many figures were
provided which are manifestly impossible. For instance, one
Gadjah Mada University scholar, writing on the Indonesian
Democratic Party of Struggle (PDI Perjuangan), estimates the
breakdown in the directly elected part of the DPR as follows: PDI
29 percent, the Golkar Party 20 percent, the National Awakening
Party (PKB) 11 percent and PAN 10 percent. No methodology was
mentioned. Among the Luddites who make implausible predictions
and never mention polls as evidence, are two executives of a
University of Indonesia-based polling organization.
Though neither of the following thoughts contributed to the
present conclusions, they may help to reconcile us to the thought
that one party may emerge with a substantial absolute majority,
and that the opposition is going to be very weak for a long time.
First, when a population is suddenly able to vote on its
destiny for the first time ever, or in decades, it typically
gives near-absolute hegemony to one party. Examples are Nehru,
Nkrumah, Kaunda, Nyerere, Mandela, Tunku Abdulrahman and Aung San
Suu Kyi. This did not happen in 1955 in Indonesia because the
main parties had entrenched organizations and were competing
against each other, not the government. In the other cases,
people saw themselves as voting for the opposition against the
dictatorship, or against colonial rule.
Second, the pattern of aliran (underlying religious-cultural
commitments) is not very relevant anymore. This is not to say
PAN, PKB and PDI Perjuangan will do equally well, or badly,
everywhere. Regional variations show up in the polls. But those
polls are now four months old and do not take into account the
crossover factor I am trying to allow for.
What I am saying is that tens of millions of people will go
over to PAN who come from environments otherwise disposed aliran-
wise. His vote is clearly going to greatly exceed the 22 percent
obtained by the Masyumi in 1955. There is abundant evidence that
Amien-mania is spreading into environments that are meant to be
opponent strongholds.
Three examples follow: First, systematic polling of Gadjah
Mada University students showed Amien beating Megawati about
60/20, with the rest going to radical favorites. The alma mater
factor? Sure, but it is still undoing current aliran ties.
Remember how popular Masyumi was at Gadjah Mada University in the
Old Order days? Kind of like Bush among black Americans.
Second, poll results reported from Bandar Lampung
universities, showed Megawati and Amien were streets ahead of
other campaigners, but Amien was slightly preferred over
Megawati. Yet Lampung is meant to be Megawati country.
Third, a few weeks ago, after speaking to about 250 students
at the Walisongo State Islamic Institute in Semarang, Central
Java, I asked them to help me with my polling. Who will vote
Megawati? Three people raised their hands. PKB? PPP? About 40
hands were raised, but there was scattered jeering from other
students.
Does that mean the rest will vote PAN? I asked. Instead of
hands, great shouts of Hidup (Long live) PAN! Hidup Amien!
ensued. The rector, Zam Dhofier, was appalled. It was really
weird to see such a demonstration from students who would nearly
all come from Nahdlatul Ulama (NU) families; many had received
pesantren (Islamic boarding school) educations. This can not be
alma mater-credited. It shows conclusively that the educated
young are moving en masse over to PAN, right across aliran lines,
which mean nothing to them any more.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/pan-likely-to-dominate-june-general-election-1447893297-1445677)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post