Palangka Raya Residents Affected by Forest and Land Fires Challenge Disaster Management Law
Jakarta (ANTARA) – Four residents of Palangka Raya affected by forest and land fires have petitioned the Constitutional Court (MK) for a judicial review of Law No. 24 of 2007 on Disaster Management.
According to the Court’s official website and YouTube channel in Jakarta on Friday, the petitioners—Damai Alam Usop, Krismen Santo Sihaloho, Davit Purwodesrantau and Paulus Alfons Yance Dhanarto—are challenging the phrase “adequate” in Article 6(e) and Article 8(d) of the Disaster Management Law.
In their petition, registered as case No. 369/PUU-XXIV/2026, the petitioners argue that the phrase “adequate” in the articles provides no benchmark for assessing whether disaster-management funding is sufficient.
“The constitutional issue raised by the petitioners is therefore not the absence of a mitigation obligation in the Disaster Management Law, but the absence of a minimum benchmark linking the obligation to allocate ‘adequate’ funding to risks and needs that can be identified and measured before and during disaster management,” Aryo Nugroho Waluyo, the petitioners’ lawyer, said at a preliminary hearing attended by the petitioners online on Thursday (8 October).
He said the petitioners had suffered constitutional harm because haze in Palangka Raya had affected them, and that this was connected to the phrase “adequate” in the Disaster Management Law.
The petitioners said natural disasters in Central Kalimantan, particularly haze, could be prevented. They therefore considered the phrase “adequate” unclear in the context of both prevention and response.
“We believe the causes of these forest and land fires can be predicted or mitigated. One factor behind the fires occurring now is the El Niño phenomenon, or drought,” Aryo said.
He added that the phrase “adequate” failed to guarantee fair legal certainty, and asked the Court to clarify its meaning in line with the petitioners’ requested ruling.
The preliminary hearing was presided over by a panel of constitutional justices led by Deputy Chief Justice Saldi Isra, with Adies Kadir and Liliek P. Adi as members.
In his guidance to the petitioners, Justice Adies Kadir asked them to explain their constitutional harm in greater detail and to set out the link between the fires and the phrase “adequate” they are challenging. He also asked them to explain the basis for arguing that the phrase in Article 6(e) and Article 8(d) conflicts with Article 28D(1), Article 28H(1), Article 23(1) and Article 18A(2) of the 1945 Constitution.
“Do the petitioners know how much has been allocated for forest and land fires? And how adequate is that allocation for dealing with them? How, then, can the petitioners conclude that the funding is insufficient? Why?” Adies asked.
Adies asked the petitioners to examine the State Budget Law, noting that their challenge was linked to it. He also urged them to align their claims and requested remedies.
Justice Liliek P. Adi said the phrase “adequate” was an open-ended norm, giving the parties concerned—both those using the budget and the government—the authority to determine the amount of funding considered adequate.
“Particularly in the grounds of the petition: if you feel that, as citizens living in Palangka Raya, the response to disasters has been hampered by funding, perhaps that could form part of the legal standing of those affected,” Liliek said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/palangka-raya-residents-affected-by-forest-and-land-fires-challenge-disaster-management-law-1791528832)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5778169/warga-palangka-raya-terdampak-karhutla-uji-uu-penanggulangan-bencana), translated from Indonesian