Only Four Countries Are Ready for a Major Bank Failure: Is Indonesia Among Them?
Jakarta, CNBC Indonesia – Indonesia has been listed among the countries considered unprepared to deal with the failure of a major bank. The assessment was made by the Financial Stability Board (FSB), the global financial stability oversight body.
Citing a Financial Times report, the FSB rated Indonesia “materially non-compliant” with recommendations on public-sector backstop funding mechanisms for failed banks.
The FSB reviewed 19 jurisdictions and found that four out of five major economies were not ready for the failure of a major bank. It urged many countries to take “urgent action” to establish government funding mechanisms that could act as a lender of last resort. Such mechanisms are needed to allow a failed bank to be wound down or sold safely without being nationalised.
Only Four Pass
Of the 19 jurisdictions assessed, only the United States, the United Kingdom, Japan and Hong Kong were judged fully compliant, having established liquidity facilities for banks in crisis.
One tier below, Canada, South Korea, Mexico, Singapore and South Africa were classified as “largely compliant”. Singapore was therefore the only Southeast Asian country in the review to receive a better rating than Indonesia.
Indonesia was placed in the third group alongside Australia, Brazil, China, the European Banking Union, Saudi Arabia, Switzerland and Türkiye. This was the largest group, with eight jurisdictions.
India and Argentina ranked lowest, receiving a “non-compliant” rating. The FSB said neither had any public-sector facility to provide emergency funding to a failed bank.
Questions over credibility
The FSB said most of the gaps identified related to credibility. Fewer than half of the jurisdictions had clear mechanisms capable of providing liquidity on the scale required and in time for it to be used effectively, it said.
“Having a credible public-sector backstop funding mechanism is essential. Further work is urgently needed to complete the implementation of the FSB recommendations,” said Soledad Núñez, Deputy Governor of the Bank of Spain, who led the review.
The FSB also warned that legal tools alone were not enough. “Resolution strategies can be difficult or even impossible to implement without temporary public funding, even where legal tools are available to impose losses on shareholders and recapitalise systemically important banks,” it said.
The review was published nearly two decades after the 2008 global financial crisis. Nevertheless, the FSB found that many governments had yet to put in place one of the key instruments likely to be needed if a major bank collapsed again.
Lessons from Credit Suisse
When a major bank runs into trouble, a very large amount of funding may be needed quickly to meet customer withdrawals and creditors’ claims.
That was evident when Credit Suisse was hit by crisis in 2023. Switzerland’s central bank provided emergency liquidity facilities and loans totalling CHF168 billion to keep the bank operating until its sale to UBS had been agreed. The loans were repaid or cancelled several months later.
The FSB said the rescue of Credit Suisse demonstrated that Switzerland had a “high level of preparedness”. However, it was carried out under an emergency decree, while legislation for a Swiss public liquidity backstop remains under discussion in parliament. This is why Switzerland, like Indonesia, was still rated materially non-compliant.
The European Banking Union, comprising 21 countries, has accumulated more than €81 billion in its Single Resolution Fund (SRF) for bank emergencies. However, the FSB said the fund faced uncertainty over its ability to raise additional money in debt markets if its resources were exhausted.
Argentina’s central bank said the FSB report did not reflect the condition of its banking sector. Argentina has a very small private credit market after decades of macroeconomic volatility and is now undergoing a stabilisation process under President Javier Milei.
“Capitalisation levels at Argentine banks exceed the international average, and the central bank more than meets international liquidity standards,” a central bank spokesperson said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/only-four-countries-are-ready-for-a-major-bank-failure-is-indonesia-among-them-1791597056)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/market/20261010014727-17-774892/hanya-4-negara-siap-hadapi-bank-gagal-indonesia-termasuk), translated from Indonesian