One Swipe, Rp23 Billion Gone! The Dark Side of a Live Shopping Startup
A live-streaming shopping app called Whatnot is under scrutiny not for its business growth, but for its devastating impact on some users. Sean Harding, a 45-year-old accountant, admitted to spending nearly US$1.4 million, or around Rp23 billion, in just four months after returning to his childhood hobby of collecting baseball cards through the app. The money came from his savings, personal loans, and even his corporate credit card, leading his wife to file for divorce upon discovering the total expenditure.
What makes the app so addictive is its design, which mimics social media. Algorithms randomly present content, encouraging users to constantly open the app hoping to stumble upon a desired item. The bidding process is dangerously fast, requiring just a single screen swipe without any confirmation or checkout page, leaving virtually no moment for second thoughts.
Founded seven years ago, Whatnot has become one of the fastest-growing live shopping platforms in the United States, claiming nearly 60% of the live commerce market in North America and Europe. It is backed by major investors like Andreessen Horowitz, Sequoia Capital, and CapitalG, and boasts nearly US$975 million in funding. CEO and co-founder Grant LaFontaine points to the app’s 4.7 rating on Apple’s App Store as evidence of user satisfaction, and the company has recently introduced optional spending limits and viewing time reminders.
However, stories of financial ruin persist. Julie Johnson, a 58-year-old event planner, spent approximately US$120,000 on fashion items over three years, watching live streams for six hours a day and describing herself as ‘truly addicted’ despite having no prior history of addiction. Joe Thompson, a 53-year-old nurse, lost his entire retirement savings and maxed out 13 credit cards in five months after discovering the collectible coins he purchased were manipulated and worth far less than he paid. His credit score plummeted from 753 to 563, leaving him nearly US$75,000 in debt.
Beyond excessive spending, the platform faces issues with stolen goods. Police once raided a prominent shoe seller’s warehouse on the app, seizing thousands of pairs of shoes and clothing items worth an estimated US$500,000, suspected to be stolen property.
The most controversial feature is the ‘breaks’ session, where buyers pay for a random chance to receive cards from a box opened live on camera, a practice critics liken to casino gambling. Consumer protection attorney Paul Lesko has filed arbitration claims on behalf of over 70 clients, arguing that these breaks constitute an illegal lottery under California law and operate like an unregulated online casino. Whatnot firmly denies the allegations, stating that unlike gambling, buyers always receive a product and do not walk away empty-handed.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/one-swipe-rp23-billion-gone-the-dark-side-of-a-live-shopping-startup-1785916317)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/market/20260805135155-17-756760/swipe-sekali-rp23-m-melayang-ini-sisi-gelap-startup-live-belanja), translated from Indonesian