One Judge Dissents, Argues Nadiem Makarim Should Be Acquitted in Chromebook Corruption Case
The former Minister of Education, Culture, Research, and Technology, Nadiem Makarim, has been found guilty in the corruption case involving the procurement of Chromebook laptops and Chrome Device Management (CDM). However, the verdict was not unanimous among the five members of the judicial panel.
One member of the panel, Andi Saputra, expressed a dissenting opinion from the other four judges. Andi believes that Nadi019s involvement in corruption has not been proven and that Nadiem deserves to be acquitted.
“The defendant, Nadiem Anwar Makarim, must be acquitted of all charges brought by the public prosecutor,” stated Andi while reading his dissenting opinion during the verdict session at the Jakarta Corruption Court on Tuesday (30/06/2026).
Andi referred to the series of facts and the alignment of evidence presented during the trial to reach this conclusion. He argued that a perfect causal link regarding criminal intent or unlawful actions by Nadiem could not be established.
Andi noted that Nadiem019s actions, which appeared to be criminal (actus reus), involved signing Minister of Education Regulation (Permendikbud) Number 5 of 2021 regarding the Operational Guidelines for the 2021 Regular Physical Special Allocation Fund in the Education Sector. However, Andi found from the evidence presented in court that the signing of this regulation was not strong enough to be classified as a criminal act.
“It turns out that Permendikbud 5/2021 did not lock in a specific brand, but rather locked in the operating system,” said Andi.
Andi stated that no strong evidence was found to incriminate Nadiem by the end of the evidentiary stage of the trial. He found no evidence that Nadiem instructed the other defendants in the Chromebook corruption case—namely Ibrahim Arief (alias Ibam), Mulyatsyah, and Sri Wahyuningsih—to commit corruption.
“Similarly, Ibrahim, Mulyatsyah, and Sri never provided any unlawful gifts to the defendant. Furthermore, the defendant was not proven to have directly or indirectly intervened with the procurement committee,” said Andi.
Furthermore, Andi viewed the WhatsApp group conversations occurring before Nadiem became Minister as legally unconvincing as evidence of a ‘meeting of minds’ or an agreement to commit corruption. According to Andi, those conversations were part of policy action planning for if Nadiem were successfully elected as Minister.
“Within reasonable reasoning, the defendant was not involved in the criminal acts committed jointly by defendants Mulyatsyah and Sri Wahyuningsih,” the former journalist stated.
Consequently, Andi concluded that there was insufficient or at least doubtful evidence, as it lacked clear alignment and causality. He also stated that there was no proven criminal intent or act that served as a bridge between a conflict of interest and corporate crime.
“The events occurring in close proximity—the laptop procurement policy, the state losses, and the increase in Google’s share capital in PT GoTo—are events that lack a strong causal link or cause-and-effect relationship. At the very least, this was not due to any criminal act, conflict of interest, or trading in influence by the defendant,” said Andi.
Andi also revealed that Nadiem had resigned from his company before being inaugurated as Minister. He found no facts suggesting that Nadiem continued to control the company to gain profit while serving as Minister.
“The defendant had resigned from the company (Gojek, which became GoTo) before being inaugurated. The defendant is only a minority shareholder, was never endorsed, and did not create policies to benefit the company. The defendant did not control the company from afar,” concluded Andi.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/one-judge-dissents-argues-nadiem-makarim-should-be-acquitted-in-chromebook-corruption-case-1782813209)
Originally published by Republika (https://news.republika.co.id/berita/thftu9409/satu-hakim-beda-pendapat-dan-nilai-nadiem-layak-divonis-bebas-ini-alasannya), translated from Indonesian