On-the-spot shooting of robbers: a DPR member says it is not about killing
Deputy Chairman of Commission XIII of the Indonesian House of Representatives (DPR), Andreas Hugo Pareira, said that the discourse on instructing security forces to take firm, proportionate action against mugging suspects should not be misinterpreted as an intention to extinguish lives. He reminded that the proposal to police to shoot robbers on the spot must continue to refer to the standard operating procedures for firearms use, which regulate actions taken with the aim of incapacitating rather than killing.
‘The instruction does not mean killing. Shooting on the spot could mean firing at a part of the body that would incapacitate,’ he said in a WhatsApp message on Saturday, 23 May 2026.
According to this PDIP politician, criminal acts that threaten the victims’ lives, such as robberies, deserve a response from security forces with firm, proportionate action to guarantee and protect the victims’ human rights. For him, a slack attitude by security forces toward crimes like this would only worsen harm to victims, and even to society, making the public the most disadvantaged.
However, Pareira emphasised that on-the-spot shooting must remain strictly in line with the firearms protocol and must not contravene normal procedures or human rights considerations.
‘The police are obliged to protect the public’s human rights, and also to comply with the protocol to carry out such actions,’ he said.
Earlier, the directive to shoot on the spot for robbery suspects was conveyed by the Lampung Regional Police and by Ahmad Sahroni, Deputy Chairman of Commission II, with the goal of protecting the public.
But the proposal was rejected by the Minister of Human Rights, Natalius Pigai. He said criminals, including robbers, must not be shot on the spot as this would contravene human rights.
‘Dealing with violence and violent acts, including terrorists, in international law, requires arrest,’ Pigai said.
He explained that perpetrators must be arrested in a manner that does not violate human rights, and that arresting suspects allows authorities to gather more information to investigate the crime more thoroughly.
‘If apprehended, law enforcement can gather data, facts, and information to resolve the root causes of the problem,’ said the former Commissioner of Komnas HAM.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/on-the-spot-shooting-of-robbers-a-dpr-member-says-it-is-not-about-killing-1779531607)
Originally published by Tempo (Indonesian) (https://nasional.tempo.co/read/2105061/soal-tembak-begal-di-tempat-anggota-dpr-bukan-membunuh), translated from Indonesian