Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

On the Shelves

| Source: The Jakarta Post

On the Shelves

What do America's Richard Nixon and Abdurrahman "Gus Dur" Wahid
have in common? Both were presidents who lost power largely
because of the influence of mass media, particularly print media.

Curran, professor of Communications at Goldsmiths College,
University of London, traces the emergence and development of the
mass media in Britain, showing to readers the development of the
media research from the 19th century to date, from his country of
residence and throughout the world.

Curran presents the historical narrative of each genre -- the
print media, radio and television and film -- and then shows how
these are interlinked to shape mass media as we know it.

Media studies have also shifted from the liberal theories of
the 19th century to feminism and cultural, political and
sociological studies in the next century. In the latter part of
the last century, the mass media showed its great role in shaping
not only public opinion but also policies of governments.

The book discusses in detail how the media plays a watchdog
role in today's social mosaic, comparing this with the role
played when liberal theories prevailed in Britain and the rest of
Europe.

The media used to be expected to control the government
because the latter was thought to be the seat of power, but in
contemporary society, the power has shifted to the market.

Curran eloquently describes how media barons forge close ties
with government bureaucracy in a mutually beneficial if ethically
dubious relationship. Politicians need the media to win electoral
votes, while the media barons need exclusive rights from the
government so that their media can control the market.

There is an interesting story about how media baron Rupert
Murdoch prevented HarperCollins from publishing the memoirs of
Chris Pattern, ex-governor of Hong Kong, simply because Murdoch
wanted to curry favor with the Chinese government in expanding
his operations in that country.

Curran argues that the idea of liberating the media from
government control is actually timeworn as in today's society
greater control is played by economic shareholders and business
managers.

Therefore, the media must exercise its control over the public
as much as the private sector. "A growing section of the world's
media has been taken over by major industrial and commercial
concerns such as General Electric, Westinghouse, Toshiba ... in a
development that extends from the United Sates and Japan to
Hungary and Colombia," he writes.

Finally, in this thought-provoking book, it is interesting to
ponder Curran's comment that the conglomeration of news media is
giving rise to "no-go areas where journalists were reluctant to
tread for fear of stepping on the corporate toes of a parent or
sister company".

The media, now as part of the corporate sector, is not acting
as independent watchdogs serving the public interest but more
like corporate mercenaries which adjust their critical scrutiny
to suit their private purpose. In this light, the relationship
between media and power in contemporary society becomes crystal
clear.

Media and Power; By James Curran; Routledge, London, 2002;
xi + 308 pp.

-- Lie Hua

More from 20 July 2003 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/on-the-shelves-1447899208-1371630)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print