Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

On the Shelves

| Source: The Jakarta Post

On the Shelves

Pulung Gantung - Menyingkap Tragedi Bunuh Diri di Gunungkidul
(Pulung Gantung - Uncovering Suicide Tragedy in Gunungkidul)
Darmaningtyas
Introduction by Dr. Francis Wahono
Published by Salwa Press-Yogyakarta in cooperation with Yayasan
Adikarya Ikapi and The Ford Foundation, 2002, 426 pp

Suicide is taking one's own life voluntarily and intentionally.
This absurd, fatalistic and destructive attitude usually arises
when people are desperate and do not rely on the norms of life
anymore.

Emile Durkheim, a French sociologist, calls this negative
attitude an anomie. As a pioneer of the research into suicide, he
wrote a book titled Suicide: A Study in Sociology (1968). Here,
Darmaningtyas has used the scheme of Durkheim's sociology in
writing his book, Pulung Gantung - Menyingkap Tragedi Bunuh Diri
di Gunungkidul, after conducting field research on his topic.

Suicide is a universal phenomenon. Hence, Darmaningtyas first
tries to compare suicide phenomena in different parts of the
world before he focuses his attention on the specific suicide
phenomenon called Pulung Gantung in Gunungkidul, Yogyakarta.

In Japan, suicide is closely related to dignity. So the Jibaku
tradition is not considered inherently bad. Palestinians, and
also Macan Tamil guerrillas in India, use suicides bombs as the
main means of their political struggles.

The destructive attitude among the members of extreme and
violent religious sects in developed countries like in the U.S.
is primarily caused by psychopathic personality disorders of
their sect leaders as they fail to cope with the effects of
modernism.

In poor countries like Indonesia, anomie is mainly caused by
both social deprivation and economic involution. The Pulung
Gantung suicide phenomenon is considered exceptional. These
suicides, which mostly happen in Gunungkidul, Yogyakarta, are
closely related to myth.

According to Darmaningtyas, who was born and grew up in
Gunungkidul, pulung means divine revelation and good luck. Based
upon stories handed down by word of mouth in the community, at
the beginning of phenomenon people usually see a reddish or
yellowish comet-like light with a blue aura. The light moves
towards the house of the person who is to commit suicide. Many
people usually witness this phenomenon, and hence they can
usually accept the suicide.

Based on Durkheim's sociology, Pulung Gantung is categorized
as an altruistic suicide. This most primitive type of suicide is
mostly caused by the following reasons: poverty, stupidity,
geographic isolation and altruism.

An altruistic attitude is the feeling of integrity with a
group or even major dependence upon the group. The poorer and the
more isolated the person, the bigger the altruistic attitude he
will have. Thus, collectivity will serve as a buffer to save
themselves from endless problems due to economic or geographical
restraints.

The suicide phenomenon in Gunungkidul is, in fact, not really
so different from that in other poor and remote places. Debt,
disease, disgrace and repeated failure generally are some of the
causes that lead people to commit suicide. Those who commit
suicide are mostly over 35 years old and from the lower level of
society with no permanent jobs to support themselves financially.
The peculiarity of Pulung Gantung rests on the escapism and
mysticism that is involved.

This book, unfortunately, contains circular descriptions as
regards the philosophy of death; the geographic, socioeconomic,
cultural characteristics of Gunungkidul, the phenomenon of
suicide all over the world and of suicide in Indonesia in
general.

The distinctive elaboration of Pulung Gantung suicide then
seems inadequate. The introduction from Dr. Francis Wahono, an
economist who is experienced in empowering Gunungkidul people,
however, could help the readers to understand the essence of
suicide and its relation to the myth.

In spite of its lack of systematic ideas, the book is still a
pioneer in the study of suicide in this country.

-- J. Sumardianta and Yusup Priyasudiarja

More from 28 July 2002 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/on-the-shelves-1447899208-1272054)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print