On The Shelves
On The Shelves
Menulis Politik: Indonesia sebagai Utopia;
(Writing on Politics: Indonesia as a Utopia);
By Ignas Kleden;
Kompas Book Publisher, Jakarta, 2001;
xli + 291 pages
This book is a collection of Kleden's articles published in
Kompas daily from 1982 to 2000. They are interesting to read as a
reflection of the responses that Kleden, as a non-partisan
intellectual, gave to the political events that unfurled during
the last two decades in this country.
The articles are divided into three parts: rationality of
Indonesian politics; the cultural character of Indonesian
politics, and opting for emancipation and democracy.
In the foreword, Kleden writes that as an independent or non-
partisan columnist, if he seems to take sides with one particular
political group, it is only by implication, not by choice. He
wants to stress that throughout his articles he tries to maintain
a consistency of attitude, which in turn is based on his own
conscience.
But this is really an unpopular preference as the columnist
inevitably appears inconsistent. When Abdurahmann "Gus Dur" Wahid
was elected president, Kleden gave the new president his full
support. He also supported Gus Dur to take action to put an end
to the dual function of the military.
But when Gus Dur began to interfere too much in the affairs of
the military and the police, he thought it was time to criticize
the president.
It is this attitude that Kleden clings firmly to in all his
articles. He tries his best to concentrate on problems not on
individuals or groups. By maintaining his independence he can see
the injustices and inequalities that prevail in his society. His
alertness over these matters will allow him to put in his arti
cles social facts against social expectations in the political
arena of this country.
About utopia, he writes that Indonesia's first president,
Sukarno, introduced this utopia to Indonesians in the form of the
revolution that would never end. The second president, Soeharto,
had his utopia of the Rostow-style stages of development. Both
failed because utopia is closely linked with indeterminate future
and as such both presidents could not determine the time when
this utopia would no longer be utopia any longer.
The absence of utopia after Soeharto's fall has contributed
greater complexity to the political problems in the country. It
is through an independent analysis in his articles that Kleden
hopes to help unravel this complexity and the book, of course,
must be read in this light.
-- Lie Hua
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/on-the-shelves-1447899208-1245019)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post