On the shelves
On the shelves
Linear : Poems/puisi/imaji/images;
By Taufik Darusman;
Andrew Tani & Co.;
First printing, May 2002;
xii + 86 pp
Few would disagree that Taufik Darusman is an achiever. He
used to lead the Indonesian Observer, and is the deputy publisher
of the business magazine Capital and the deputy secretary-general
of the Alliance of a New Indonesia (PIB). A newspaper editor, a
businessman, a politician. And now, with his new book, Linear,
maybe even a poet.
The goal of Linear is noble but overly grandiose: to integrate
words and images to make a complete whole, and, as Darusman
himself proposes in the foreword, to be a "celebration of life".
However, his poems are not for the light of heart. Revolving
around classic themes such as overcoming difficulty, and the
meaning of life, they are introspective, philosophical
reflections, the tone ranging from quiet desperation (see Ballad)
to inquisitive and dreamy melancholy (see Reflection #2).
Many have nihilistic undertones. In a particularly moving
passage from Reflection #3, Darusman writes: "One day to
another/Passes without/Meaning and sense/They appear alike/Moving
towards the same directions/The loss, destruction/Of purity/The
loss of balance..."
Many such poems reverberate with existentialist echoes
reminiscent of the book Ecclesiastes.
However, a few of Darusman's poems also contain glimmers of
hope to counteract that melancholy. "Is it possible/The obstacle
is/ourselves?" asks the speaker in Obstacles.
Especially inspired is the exhiliratingly joyful end of To
Whom?: "Amidst my loneliness/I notice a light/That offers hope/I
feel free/I feel released/Now..."
Darusman also catches one off guard with a couple of
touchingly sentimental, though unoriginal, love poems,
Reminiscing and Mother's Love.
Many of his poems, due to the diction and syntax, must be read
more than once to be understood. But once the meaning is
captured, they can be refreshing reads, such as Is it not?, which
addresses the individual's struggle between conforming to society
and maintaining one's identity.
However, some poems reek of cliches. In Waiting, he
pontificates that "Fate is hard to predict". As though we've
never heard that one before. "But no mountain is too high to
climb," he later writes, which instantly caused Tammy Terrell to
belt out her old hit Ain't No Mountain High Enough in my head.
Though I hardly need say it, the mood was spoiled. May 1998,
which was based on Indonesia's recent riots, is full of
predictable ideas and reads like parts of an emotional newspaper
article.
Unless you've been living in a black hole for the past 50
years, it's plain that Darusman's ideas are nothing original or
innovative.
But although, and perhaps partly because his poems are full of
familiar themes and ideas, some are moving. A few possess
insight. The reader senses that Darusman has published a slightly
edited diary, similar to one's own diary in its concerns and
feelings, and sometimes its obscure meanings to all but himself.
Sometimes his poetry overflows with heartfelt honesty in its
questions and moods, but other times it only aspires to "utter a
new word".
Darusman's terse, prose-like style supports the simple, though
important subjects of his poems.
Unfortunately, the word choice and syntax sometimes obscures
the meaning. Sometimes it seems, though as solely an English-
speaker I cannot verify, that the translator has chosen the most
complex, incomprehensible way to word a passage.
As for Darusman's attempt to integrate words and images, his
compilation is little more than some interesting poems
intermixed with postcard-pretty pictures. Like some of his
poetry, Darusman's book contains too much fluff disguised as
substance.
As a poet, Darusman may not be highly gifted, but his ability
to occasionally move the reader with raw expressions of thought
and emotion is undeniable. So is the well-developed voice that
speaks throughout his poems, which seems oddly familiar in its
heavy questions, ruminations and even its joy. Perhaps Darusman
is echoing our own inner voices. Perhaps that's why you might be
touched by Linear.
-- Tania Budihardjo
More from 1 September 2002 โ
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/on-the-shelves-1447899208-1226268)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post