On the Shelves
On the Shelves
Surat dari Palmerah: Indonesia dalam Politik Mehong 1996 - 1999
(Letters from Palmerah: Indonesia under the Mehong Politics 1996
- 1999); By Seno Gumira Ajidarma; Kepustakaan Populer Gramedia (KPG),
Jakarta, April 2002; xxii + 287 pp
Although the reform drive in Indonesia has been going on for
four years, everyone is curious if Indonesia has really changed
for the better.
Is Indonesia still trapped by the mehong politics so that the
ongoing reform is nothing but reformehong? The political show by
the political elite has only disappointed the public and to a
certain extent has lent apathy, or even pessimism, to part of the
community.
This book is a collection of editorial-like letters that Seno
wrote in Jakarta Jakarta magazine between 1996 and 1999. These
letters have some interesting aspects.
First, his choice to write an editorial in the form of a
letter seems to suggest a more liquid form of communication
generating a greater personal and humanitarian touch on the part
of the readers. Perhaps, Seno saw something wrong in the
communications involving all national elements. He may have seen
the result is only a fawning attitude or a mentality fraught with
revenge and animosity.
Second, given the fact that the readers of Jakarta Jakarta
were mostly young executives who the New Order regime had
alienated from the political realm, these letters in a certain
sense could serve as an interesting medium of political education
as they were intended for the middle-class people.
Sometimes, the letters very explicitly show this direction,
especially when the writer uses words like yuppies and the like.
The next interesting aspect of these letters is they are
conveyed in a good and interesting narrative flow, interspersed
with sarcasm, worries, reflection, wisdom, comedy or a ridicule
of our political life.
When Seno put under his spotlight the never-ending violent
communal conflicts, he took the viewpoint of how the community
got themselves trapped in the prison or labyrinth of animosity.
He described how people were no longer masters of themselves
and willingly allowed themselves to be the slaves of
unconsciousness called animosity, ambition or revenge. At this
point, Seno made a conclusion that the reform was yet to produce
a significant change, particularly in the political culture of
everyday life.
Indeed, political ideology has found its freedom of
expression. Unfortunately, it still came from a hypocritical and
arrogant cultural tradition. Comically, Seno poses a question:
While someone's mental crisis can be addressed by a psychologist
or a witch doctor, what about a mentally ailing nation?
The acute ailment that this nation is afflicted with seems to
be slowly leading it towards destruction. In the other part of
the book, he also gives his warning that if you have an excessive
desire to put down conflicts and anarchy for the sake of
orderliness, the result will often be another form of anarchy.
Seno has touched the nation's political culture, an aspect of
life which is yet to undergo substantial changes. It is true that
it is now rare to find physical or militaristic repression of the
New Order regime, but a conspiracy of oppression, which the
illegal product of power that colludes with ignorance and
deception, is not rare to find.
While the political elite are busy vying for power, the little
people have been duped. While in fact these little people are the
reform and development heroes, they have been turned into mere
commodities.
In one of the letters, Seno rhetorically asks: "Do you know
who has built Indonesia? They have no seats. They are the people
that have been sacrificed."
In this context, the perspective of a political education
intended to improve the political intelligence of the people and
encourage their political participation has assumed great
importance for a discussion. Seno criticizes the elite on the
political stage because they provide little education to the
people. Their speeches are rarely based on the clarity of their
mind and a well-arranged thinking system. Their words sometimes
resemble curses smacking of trash, provocations or an outburst of
their personal emotion or the emotion of their own group.
His letters are good to read and observe. They will encourage
us to reflect together upon the process of changes now under way
in this country and ensure that in this way the victims of
changes and reform, already quite big in number, will not just
vanish.
-- M. Mushthafa
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/on-the-shelves-1447899208-1221419)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post