Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

On the record

| Source: The Jakarta Post

On the record

Artist : Erwin Gutawa

Album : Salute to Koes Plus/Bersaudara (Sony Music Indonesia)

Making a cover album is a tricky business, especially when it is
a tribute to a legendary band.

Koes Plus and Koes Brothers have touched people with their
songs -- catchy and simple, yet infused with depth and soul --
since they emerged in the 1960s.

Those are the qualities missing on this cover album.

Praise must be given to noted musician/conductor Erwin for
saluting the legendary musicians, but the result is soulless and,
at times, overpolished with orchestra and the trimmings.

The lineup of artists contributes to the problems, as almost
all of them were picked simply because they are with Sony.

It is not all bad, with Jemu (Weary), originally a rock
number, getting quite a kick with synth and sax. Bunga Di Tepi
Jalan (Flower on the Side of the Street) is also OK, as well as
the jazzy O La La.

But what's up with Rio Febrian and Ruth Sahanaya going way
overboard on songs that are supposed to be sweet and simple?

And Mari Berjoget means "let's dance", but Cokelat band's
vocalist Kikan sings it like she is bored to death.

Perhaps it is time for the local industry to do some
remastering of oldies, instead of butchering them. -- Hera Diani

More from 8 August 2004 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/on-the-record-1447899208-1495676)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print