On the record
On the record
Artist : Melly Goeslaw and Anto Hoed
Album : Eiffel I'm In Love, Original Motion Picture Soundtrack
(PT Aquarius Musikindo)
Their success coming up with the soundtrack for 2002's teen hit
Ada Apa Dengan Cinta? (What's Up With Cinta?) invited an offer
for Anto and Melly to do the same for Eiffel...I'm In Love.
Unfortunately, unlike the fresh and catchy previous work, this
sophomore effort by singer/songwriter Melly and her musician
husband just does not work.
First, the songs are not engaging. For a light and happy teen
romance like Eiffel, the selection of music -- a mix of pop, rock
and techno, plus a few heartrending ballads -- is sometimes too
complicated and gloomy.
Melly tries to be trendy by going R&B in Kamu (You) which
turns out lame, but worse still is Avril Lavigne's Skater Boi
wannabe Dunia Milik Berdua (The World is Ours).
Thirdly, and most fatal of all, this album sounds like Melly
repeating herself, signs of which actually began to be seen on
the Ada Apa soundtrack. So, this album is only a repetition of
her past works, both the soundtrack project and her solo albums.
Only, second time around, it has lost its charm.-- Hera Diani
More from 14 December 2003 โ
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/on-the-record-1447899208-1329725)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post