On Nicotine Restrictions, Agriculture Ministry: Decades of Research Pose a Challenge
The plan to limit nicotine and tar levels has met firm opposition from tobacco farmers, with discussions still mired in debate over the cross-sector regulatory impact. However, the Ministry of Agriculture, which is responsible for managing this strategic commodity’s varieties, has not been fully involved.
"The Ministry of Agriculture was not comprehensively involved in these discussions because the draft regulation is based on a mandate from the Health Law (downstream/consumption aspect) rather than the agriculture law (upstream/production aspect). Nevertheless, the Ministry of Agriculture continues to provide support in the form of necessary data related to the tobacco commodity," said Yudi Wahyudi, Head of the Seasonal Crops Group at the Ministry of Agriculture’s Directorate of Seasonal Crops, as quoted on Monday (27/7/2026).
In the process of discussing the draft regulation on nicotine and tar limits, Yudi explained that from the upstream/production side of tobacco plants, at least 30 years are needed to provide certainty so that researchers at the National Research and Innovation Agency (BRIN) and the Ministry of Agriculture can find low-nicotine varieties that remain robust in tropical lands and efficient for traditional farmers.
"Without a transition period this long, the local industry is certain to collapse before the ideal seed is even developed. Lowering nicotine levels in tobacco plants through traditional cross-breeding (non-GMO) requires a very lengthy genetic selection process. Each plant generation requires one full growing season. To stabilise the low-nicotine trait without damaging the plant’s resistance to local pests, dozens of cross-breeding generations are needed. Moreover, the nicotine content of local Indonesian tobacco (such as Kemloko in Temanggung or Mole in West Java) ranges from 3% to 8% due to volcanic soil factors and tropical sunlight exposure," Yudi explained.
He stressed that drastically altering this nicotine content is tantamount to changing the geographical identity of the commodity, which ultimately requires a natural adaptation period spanning generations of farmers. Meanwhile, from an economic perspective, if these restrictions eventually force a reduction in tobacco acreage, the country needs at least one generation (around 25-30 years) to educate and transition millions of farmers to substitute commodities of equivalent economic value. Yudi acknowledged that obtaining tobacco with very low nicotine levels of <1% or equivalent to <10 mg/g in dried leaves to achieve cigarette smoke emissions of <1 mg represents the greatest biological challenge for Indonesian agriculture.
"This is because the tobacco plant is a highly site-specific commodity, where the plant’s genetic interaction with the local climate and soil determines the final result. Furthermore, tobacco farmers will assess whether these low-nicotine and low-tar tobacco varieties have a market or economic value comparable to the local varieties they have been cultivating. Farmers will look at the profitability aspect before deciding to cultivate the new tobacco varieties," he stated.
Yudi explained that agronomically and scientifically, reducing nicotine to such extreme levels can be pursued through three main pathways: first, through Conventional Cross-Breeding, namely mating superior local varieties with strong physical characteristics with foreign varieties that are genetically very low in nicotine. Second, Modern Genetic Engineering (CRISPR Gene Editing), which involves switching off or deactivating the specific enzyme-producing genes in the roots where nicotine is produced before it is transported to the leaves. And third, Modification of Cultivation Techniques (Agronomy), namely completely changing traditional planting methods, such as reducing Nitrogen (N) fertiliser, not performing topping, and maintaining adequate water supply, which can significantly suppress nicotine accumulation in the leaves.
"In general, there are no pure local Indonesian varieties that fall below 1%. The majority of our chopped and kretek tobaccos (such as those from Temanggung, Boyolali, or Garut) naturally range between 3% and 8%. Scientifically, a 30-year timeframe cannot provide an absolute guarantee that a single new variety can grow uniformly across all of Indonesia. The inherent characteristics of tobacco are tied to the concept of Terroir (soil suitability, elevation, weather, and local micro-climate)," he concluded.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/on-nicotine-restrictions-agriculture-ministry-decades-of-research-pose-a-challenge-1785117049)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/news/20260726165143-4-753886/soal-pembatasan-nikotin-kementan-riset-puluhan-tahun-jadi-tantangan), translated from Indonesian