On National reconciliation
On National reconciliation
Mr. B.J. Habibie's government is becoming a government of
nouns instead of verbs: a government comprised of teams and
commissions and institutes instead of a government energized by
deciding and executing and implementing. Investigations and
initiatives are begun, then seem to be aborted or just quietly
expire. (Whatever happened to the Jamsostek billions?). Regarding
who is guilty of what, no one is ever the wiser, and few seem
held accountable.
Does Indonesia really need a National Reconciliation Team?
Look at how many newly formed groups of intelligent, well-
intentioned experts are already attacking Indonesia's problems.
There is nary a niche left for another group. If the government
has not yet acted on the many recommendations, suggestions,
demands that have already been put to it, how will another set of
statements from a new team make any difference in the country's
mood?
A complaint is a gift, proclaims one popular customer service
book title. Every day in this and other newspapers and in TV
interviews, Indonesians offer President Habibie many gifts: clues
to what it will take to reconcile them with their government and
with each other. Food prices. May riots and rapes. Aceh. Tanjung
Priok. Discriminatory citizenship rules. East Timor. The
Indonesian Democratic Party (PDI). Profiteering. Corruption,
collusion and nepotism (KKN). The Soeharto clan's wealth. Human
rights violations by the Armed Forces (ABRI). Unscrupulous
bankers. Poor public service. Et cetera, et cetera. It does not
take a rocket scientist or an aeronautical engineer to know what
issues are dividing the community from the government and from
each other. Why doesn't the country's leading engineer fathom
this? This government has in fact taken many remarkable steps in
the right direction. But a few first steps do not a reform make.
Once, people could be silenced by a few conciliatory words: not
now. People are demanding results. Results that are responsive to
people's demands will lead to reconciliation. Credible results
are not yet being delivered.
No, what is lacking is not prescriptions but action: follow-
through, follow-up, feedback. Another discussion group is not
what will reconcile the fractured nation. Solutions to the
problems people have already articulated will reconcile the
nation. Give people transparent, honest progress reports on what
stage the various task forces are and what concrete steps will be
next. Let Minister of Information Muhammad Yunus brief the people
each week on the status of the major ongoing investigations, one
by one. Let him appoint a staff member to monitor TV reports and
letters to the editors of all major newspapers for questions,
complaints and suggestions in the public sphere. Respond to, act
on these, and every week report to the people on how the
administration has handled the previous week's "gifts". Show
people that the government is not stalemated and not
stonewalling.
Reconciliation will begin when the government begins to
deliver results responsive to the matters that most concern
people.
On hearsay evidence: A reply to Mr. Dupuis.
In his Sept. 9 letter, Mr. C. Dupuis asked whether I was
speaking from personal knowledge or casually passing along
hearsay when I wrote about corruption in international aid
projects. Was I from cowardice failing to name names; or did I on
the other hand make empty accusations recklessly? Mr. Dupuis has
asked for my candid acknowledgement.
I did not witness the corruption I described (e.g. a payoff or
kickback as it was taking place). In an American court of law my
statements would be considered "hearsay", that is, assertions by
someone who did not witness the act him/herself, but who heard
the account from a witness. Hearsay evidence standing alone is
generally not admissible in court (at least in the U.S.) because
it is secondhand evidence; it needs further verification.
Hearsay evidence is not necessarily lacking in truthfulness.
DONNA K. WOODWARD
Medan, North Sumatra
More from 14 September 1998 โ
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/on-national-reconciliation-1447893297-1375459)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post