On KUHAP Challenge at Constitutional Court, Eddy Hiariej Says Pre-trial Reviews Cannot Be Staggered: ‘That’s a Ploy’
Deputy Law Minister Edward Omar Sharif Hiariej (Eddy Hiariej), representing the President, gave testimony at a Constitutional Court hearing on challenges to the Criminal Procedure Code (KUHAP). He said pre-trial reviews must not be filed in instalments, describing that approach as a ploy.
Hiariej made the remarks during hearings in cases No. 313, 316 and 317/PUU-XXIV/2026 at the Constitutional Court building in Central Jakarta on Monday (19 October 2026). He was accompanied by National Police Legal Division chief Inspector General Ahrie Sonta.
The hearing began with Constitutional Court Chief Justice Suhartoyo asking whether someone could file for a pre-trial review more than once. He cited the possibility of a person challenging a subsequent coercive measure after an earlier pre-trial ruling.
For example, a suspect might first challenge their designation as a suspect, and a pre-trial judge would issue a ruling. Investigators might then take another coercive measure, such as a search or seizure.
Suhartoyo asked whether the person could still seek a pre-trial review of that subsequent measure.
“If a coercive measure only arises after the pre-trial process—for example, a subsequent coercive measure taken while a pre-trial review is under way—is that also barred?” Suhartoyo asked.
Hiariej replied that the House of Representatives’ initial draft of the KUHAP Bill would have allowed a person to seek a pre-trial review for each coercive measure. He said the draft listed six types of coercive measure, and the Government added three during deliberations, bringing the total to nine under the KUHAP.
“Your Honours, the Constitutional Court justices, can imagine that if each coercive measure could be challenged once through a pre-trial review, nine measures could mean nine pre-trial reviews. That would delay the resolution of a case, and delaying the resolution of a case is the same as delaying justice,” Hiariej said.
He added that the Government had proposed allowing only one pre-trial review so that proceedings on the substance of the case would not be delayed.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/on-kuhap-challenge-at-constitutional-court-eddy-hiariej-says-pre-trial-reviews-cannot-be-staggered-thats-a-1792414232)
Originally published by VIVA.co.id (https://www.viva.co.id/berita/nasional/1937064-soal-gugatan-kuhap-di-mk-eddy-hiariej-tak-boleh-nyicil-nyicil-itu-namanya-akal-akalan), translated from Indonesian