Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

On Expiring Quota, Constitutional Court Judge: I Bought 10 GB, But After Using 9 GB It's Already Finished

| | Source: Kompas Translated from Indonesian | Legal
On Expiring Quota, Constitutional Court Judge: I Bought 10 GB, But After Using 9 GB It's Already Finished
Image: Kompas

Constitutional Court Justice Guntur Hamzah once again questioned why quotas purchased by the public in the form of data packages disappear due to time limits. He gave an example where the public buys a 10 Gigabyte (GB) quota for Rp 25,000. However, after using only 9 GB, the remaining quota expires because the usage period has ended. “From the perspective of the public, customers, and subscribers, they say, ‘I bought Rp 25,000 for 10 Gigabytes, but why after 9 GB it’s already finished’ (cannot be used anymore),” said Guntur Hamzah during the hearing for Case Number 33/PUU-XXIV/2026 and 273/PUU-XXIII/2025 on Monday (4/5/2026). The public considers internet quotas as the purchase of goods that fully belong to them after the transaction. Meanwhile, operators view it as a form of service. “You say this is a service, this is a jasa, while the public sees it as goods,” he stated. However, the public’s view is considered to have a strong legal basis. Guntur Hamzah referred to Supreme Court jurisprudence which states there are invisible goods, such as electricity flow which is now also paid using tokens and electricity flow quotas. “But is this not goods? Don’t blame the public, many professors send me SMS saying ‘that’s (internet quota) not a service, that’s goods’,” he said. Guntur stated that a middle ground is needed in the differing perceptions between the public and mobile operators. One of them is by giving customers the freedom of choice regarding the service packages they select. “Just give options, there are choices based on time, there are choices based on, for example, how many gigas, like that,” he emphasised. In the same hearing, Indosat’s VP Head of Prepaid Product and Pricing Strategy, Nicholas Yulius Munandar, explained that for volume-based services without time limits, Indosat considers that model risky for network management and potentially drives tariff increases.

More from 5 May 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/on-expiring-quota-constitutional-court-judge-i-bought-10-gb-but-after-using-9-gb-its-already-finished-1777942357)
Originally published by Kompas (https://nasional.kompas.com/read/2026/05/05/07032641/soal-kuota-hangus-hakim-mk-saya-beli-10-gb-baru-pakai-9-gb-sudah-selesai?utm_source=ABC&utm_medium=rss), translated from Indonesian
Print