Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

On Chinese Indonesians

| Source: The Jakarta Post

On Chinese Indonesians

May I respond to Ms. Rahayu Ratnaningsih's comments in her
July 31 letter on two of my earlier letters. Ms. Ratnaningsih
believes that my first letter showed a disregard for the
magnitude of the discrimination suffered by Chinese-Indonesians.
She also suggests that in the second letter I have generalized
that all Chinese get special treatment in the business sector,
and that all Chinese businesspeople are guilty of collusion.

If this is what Ms. Ratnaningsih thinks I am saying in my
letters or if she thinks that this is what I believe, then my
words have been gravely misunderstood. I thought it was clear
from my statement taken as a whole that I was not referring to
all Chinese-Indonesians, or even to all Chinese businesspeople,
when I spoke of corruption in the Chinese business community. But
in rereading those letters, I see that there are several places
where I might have added a "some" to make this clearer. I can
only say that Ms. Ratnaningsih's perception of my feelings about
Chinese-Indonesians or their experiences of discrimination and
violence is incorrect. I hope that no Chinese-Indonesian who
knows me -- and most of my closest Indonesian friends are from
this community -- would share Ms. Ratnaningsih's misunderstanding
on this point. There is no more insidious social disease, I
believe, than that of racism. Like its sibling, poverty, racism
destroys dignity, human hope, and a sense of empowerment. But
because it is grounded in features like skin color or facial
features, which a person cannot change, racism is far more
difficult to escape,

Racism: the ascription of status and privilege and power (or
access to power) within a community on the basis of race. This is
one definition of racism. One of the idiosyncrasies of racism in
Indonesia is that neither of the two major racial groups is
universally privileged. In law, the indigenous Indonesians are
privileged; in commerce, the Chinese ascended to the position of
privilege. What were the causes of this generations-old
phenomenon? Who if anyone is to be blamed or credited for these
developments? To what degree are the related stereotypes that
each group has of the other, grounded in experience?

These issues have appeared and reappeared in articles and
emotion-laden letters in the past two months. The questions and
the need to debate them are obviously vital to those who feel
that they have been victimized by the other group's (indigenous
or Chinese-Indonesian) racism. But the depth of race-related
pain and anger, for both indigenous Indonesians and Chinese-
Indonesians, seems to obstruct communication and understanding
between the two groups, at least for the time being.

Ms. Ratnaningsih and I agree on a fundamental point: on July
28, Ms. Ratnaningsih wrote, "I think the real issue is not about
Chinese versus indigenous Indonesians but the gap between rich
and poor." On June 16 I wrote, "Ordinary Chinese and indigenous
people are both victims of the collusive partnership between
high-level indigenous officials and Chines owners of Indonesia's
megabusinesses." But I cannot agree with these Chinese-
Indonesians, even when they are my closest friends, who can see
only their own group's victimization and oppression at the hands
of the Indonesian community, and not the victimization and
oppression that the Indonesian community has also endured in the
economic sector (including commerce and employment), where the
Chinese business community dominates.

Boris Pasternak wrote, "We are all made of the same clay."
More important than the intergroup conflicts Indonesians have
finally begun to address, more significant than the cultural,
ethnic, gender, religious, racial and social differences that
often divide us from one another, is our deeper, inevitable
connectedness that Pasternak alluded to.

DONNA K. WOODWARD

Medan, North Sumatra

More from 20 August 1998 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/on-chinese-indonesians-1447893297-1404427)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print