Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

On 80th Anniversary, Polri's Law Enforcement and Oversight Remain Major Challenges, Says Analyst

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Legal
On 80th Anniversary, Polri's Law Enforcement and Oversight Remain Major Challenges, Says Analyst
Image: Media Indonesia

The 80th anniversary of the Indonesian National Police (Polri) serves as a critical moment to evaluate the quality of public services, law enforcement, and the strengthening of oversight systems amidst the implementation of Law Number 5 of 2026 regarding the National Police.

Bambang Rukminto, a policing observer from the Institute for Security and Strategic Studies (ISESS), stated that police services have shown progress in recent years, particularly through the optimisation of public complaint services via the 110 hotline, which has become more accessible to the public.

“Regarding services, it cannot be denied that there have been improvements. The 110 hotline platform, for instance, has been massively promoted as an effort to increase responsiveness to public complaints,” Bambang told Media Indonesia on Wednesday (1/7).

However, he assessed that these improvements in service have not been accompanied by increased transparency and accountability in law enforcement. He noted that the low rate of crime reporting to the police serves as an indicator that public trust in the law enforcement process is still weak.

“In terms of transparency and accountability in law enforcement, it is still far from expectations. Looking at the Crime Statistics released annually by BPS, only about 22 per cent of crime victims report to the police. This can be interpreted as the public not yet fully trusting police services in law enforcement,” he said.

According to Bambang, the greatest challenge for the National Police in the information technology era is no longer merely increasing operational capabilities, but building transparency and accountability that can be justified to the public.

“Transparency and accountability require strong control and oversight. This is a future challenge for the National Police and an opportunity for National Police Chief General Listyo Sigint Prabowo to leave a legacy for the institution he leads,” he said.

Furthermore, Bambang highlighted the oversight system regulated under the National Police Law Number 5 of 2026. He assessed that the internal oversight mechanism regulated in Article 19A is still unable to meet accountability demands because it is still conducted by the same institution.

“Article 19A remains a self-regulation mechanism because it is carried out by the same institution. Traditionally, the public uses the term ‘it is impossible for an orange to eat an orange,’ so the effectiveness of internal oversight remains a question,” he remarked.

Meanwhile, external oversight through the National Police Commission (Kompolnas) is also deemed insufficiently strong. Bambang explained that based on Articles 38 and 39, Kompolnas only has the authority to provide advice and considerations, conduct monitoring, and receive public complaints.

“Kompolnas does not possess investigative powers or the authority to impose binding sanctions on the National Police. Consequently, the available external oversight lacks the coercive power comparable to the vast authority of the institution being supervised,” he said.

On this basis, he assessed that the weakness of these oversight mechanisms makes substantive institutional reform within the police difficult to achieve, despite the existence of a new legal framework.

“With this new legal foundation, it is very difficult to carry out substantive cultural reform efforts. Longstanding public grievances, such as impunity, conflicts of interest, officer arrogance through criminalisation, lack of meritocracy within the ranks, patronage, and selective law enforcement, remain unaddressed in the new Law,” he concluded.

More from 1 July 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/on-80th-anniversary-polris-law-enforcement-and-oversight-remain-major-challenges-says-analyst-1782892271)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/906258/hut-ke-80-polri-pengamat-sebut-penegakan-hukum-dan-pengawasan-masih-jadi-pr-besar), translated from Indonesian
Print