Oil Price Decline Does Not Automatically Shrink Budget Deficit, Economist Warns
The easing of global oil prices following the reduction in tensions between the United States and Iran does not necessarily guarantee a reduction in the state budget (APBN) deficit. Ariyo DP Irhamna, an economist from the Institute for Development ofES Economics and Finance (Indef), suggests that while falling oil prices may reduce the potential for energy subsidy expansion, they do not automatically improve the government’s fiscal position.
According to Ariyo, the fiscal space created by reduced subsidy pressure may not be used to curb the deficit. Referring to statements from Finance Minister Purbaya Yudhi Sadewa, this budgetary space is instead likely to be reallocated to fund the government’s priority programmes. “By design, this is a reallocation of expenditure, so the claim of improving the deficit does not automatically apply,” Ariyo told Media Indonesia on Tuesday.
He noted that while projections for energy subsidy savings are possible, the value is expected to be less significant than anticipated. This is because the current situation represents a reduction in the potential for subsidy expansion rather than a saving against the already established budget ceiling. Ariyo explained that the Indonesian Crude Price (ICP) remains at US$91.9 per barrel, significantly higher than the state budget assumption of US$70 per barrel. As long as oil prices do not return to that assumption, the subsidy burden is expected to remain above budget.
Furthermore, the widening of subsidies is influenced not only by oil prices but also by the Rupiah exchange rate, which remains around Rp17,700 per US dollar. Without a corresponding strengthening of the Rupiah, falling oil prices will not automatically cut energy subsidy burdens. Additionally, because the ICP is calculated using an annual average, periods of high prices will continue to impact the total subsidy amount. “A sharp decline now only limits the annual average to a certain extent,” said Ariyo.
He added that the impact of lower global oil prices on the fiscal situation should be distinguished between short-term effects and long-term fiscal resilience. As a net importer of fuel, Indonesia benefits when oil prices fall because subsidy savings generally outweigh the decrease in state revenue from the oil and gas sector. However, he noted that this condition is merely a cyclical relaxation due to easing external shocks, rather than a structural strengthening of the fiscal foundation.
Ariyo emphasised that fiscal resilience is determined by strong tax revenues and disciplined state expenditure management, rather than global commodity fluctuations beyond government control. Relying on geopolitical de-escalation as a fiscal cushion indicates a vulnerability in the state budget structure.
From a sectoral perspective, falling oil prices are deemed most beneficial for the transport and logistics sectors, as fuel is a primary operational cost. The aviation industry is also highly sensitive given that avtur accounts for a large portion of business costs. Additionally, energy-intensive industries and those using petroleum derivatives, such as petrochemicals, plastics, and fertilisers, stand to benefit.
Lower distribution costs could also potentially dampen inflation, supporting public purchasing power and providing a positive impact on the retail, food, and beverage sectors. Conversely, the upstream oil and gas sector and state revenue from energy commodities face potential pressure. As an exporter of coal and liquefied natural gas (LNG), Indonesia also faces a potential decline in export revenues if energy prices weaken broadly. “The net effect is positive for consumers and energy-using industries, but neutral to negative for the energy export sector and terms of trade,” said Ariyo.
Meanwhile, energy observer from Padjadjaran University (Unpad), Yayan Satyakti, believes that the easing of the US-Iran conflict still presents opportunities for energy subsidy savings. He noted that global oil prices affect the Mean of Platts Singapore (MOPS), which serves as a benchmark for setting non-subsidised fuel prices such as Pertalite and Pertamax.
Yayan explained that when global oil prices fall, MOPS also decreases, thereby reducing fiscal pressure. “Consequently, our fiscal burden will decrease,” said Yayan. He added that reduced pressure on energy subsidies has the potential to improve the state budget deficit, as the difference in lower oil prices can expand the government’s fiscal space, assuming consumption volumes remain constant. Several business sectors are expected to benefit from this condition, including the hydrocarbon, petrochemical, ammonia, plastic, and fertiliser industries, as well as the international transport and logistics sectors.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/oil-price-decline-does-not-automatically-shrink-budget-deficit-economist-warns-1781601617)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/ekonomi/901011/harga-minyak-mereda-defisit-apbn-belum-tentu-menyusut), translated from Indonesian