Observer Urges Temporary Suspension of Umrah Departures
Jakarta (ANTARA) - Sharia economist Imas Damayanti of Paramadina University has urged the Indonesian Government to temporarily suspend Umrah departures to Saudi Arabia amid escalating geopolitical tensions on the Arabian Peninsula.
“Indonesia should suspend Umrah departures for our pilgrims to Saudi Arabia until the conflict has subsided,” Imas said in a statement in Jakarta on Tuesday.
She said the conflict not only threatened security but was also a disruptive factor in the global economic landscape.
According to Imas, the conflict between Saudi Arabia and the Houthis affects the organisation of Umrah in Saudi Arabia. Security concerns and discomfort during worship, she said, would weigh on pilgrims.
From the perspective of Islamic economics, the situation calls not only for macroeconomic analysis of material losses but also for a reconsideration of fiqh al-awlawiyyat (the jurisprudence of priorities), based on the Maqashid Sharia framework, to formulate public-interest policies that mitigate risks.
Imas acknowledged that, under Saudi Vision 2030, religious tourism, including the Hajj and Umrah, is projected to be a key pillar in diversifying Saudi Arabia’s non-oil economy.
She said the absence of Indonesian Umrah pilgrims would affect security and trigger a significant supply-and-demand shock to the Saudi Kingdom’s external balance of payments.
In Indonesia, meanwhile, the number of pilgrims travelling for Umrah is also considered highly influential to the sustainability of the domestic Umrah travel business ecosystem.
In macroeconomic terms, she estimated that the average expenditure associated with one Umrah visit to Saudi Arabia—including accommodation, domestic transport, food and land arrangements—amounts to around US$1,000–1,200 per pilgrim.
“Is the economic impact on Saudi Arabia and Indonesia worth the risk to pilgrims’ safety? I don’t think so. Pilgrims’ safety must come first,” she said.
Imas added that, as a sovereign country, Indonesia had an obligation to protect its citizens from the threat posed by international conflicts.
She called on the Government to act prudently, not merely warning Umrah pilgrims to be careful in Saudi Arabia but also taking a firm stance by prohibiting its citizens from travelling there for the pilgrimage.
The Ministry of Hajj and Umrah said no Indonesian Umrah pilgrims had so far been directly affected by the situation and that all stages of the pilgrimage were proceeding as usual.
As a precaution, the ministry advised pilgrims currently in Saudi Arabia to remain calm, stay alert and focus on their worship in Makkah and Madinah.
Pilgrims were asked to limit non-essential travel outside those areas, follow all instructions from local authorities, avoid potentially dangerous locations and maintain active contact with their travel agencies.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/observer-urges-temporary-suspension-of-umrah-departures-1791892531)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5783797/pengamat-sarankan-tunda-sementara-keberangkatan-jamaah-umrah), translated from Indonesian