Observer Urges House Commission II to Immediately Discuss Election Law Revision
The coordinator of the Indonesian Electoral Committee (Tepi), Jeirry Sumampow, has urged the DPR RI Commission II and the government to immediately commence discussions on the revision of the Election Law. This step is deemed urgent following numerous recent Constitutional Court (MK) rulings that must be accommodated within the regulations.
Jeirry considers the DPR’s reasoning—that the Election Law revision is not yet urgent and thus excluded from the 202ng priority National Legislative Programme (Prolegnas)—to be questionable. He noted that drafts and materials for the revision have been circulating since 2021 before eventually stalling.
“If the DPR now claims that revising the law is not too urgent and therefore not a priority for 2026, we find this somewhat strange,” Jeirry stated during an online discussion on Wednesday (17/6).
According to Jeirry, there are at least three recent Constitutional Court rulings post-2021 that are crucial to include in the revision draft. One of these is Constitutional Court Decision Number 135/PUU-XXII/2024, which mandates the separation of the schedules for National General Elections and Local Elections (Pilkada), with a gap of at least two years and a maximum of 2.5 years.
Jeirry questioned whether there is political reluctance from the DPR or the government to accommodate these legal decisions, as they may conflict with the political narrative the state intends to build.
“We see no reason to delay, unless there is indeed a political motive. If they disagree with the Constitutional Court’s decision, they should not simply avoid discussing this law,” he said.
Furthermore, Jeirry expressed concern regarding the pattern of law-making by the DPR recently, which he believes often negates public participation. He cited the discussion process for the Police Law revision, which suddenly appeared in a plenary session without prior transparency.
Jeirry suspects a similar strategy might be applied to the Election Law revision. He suggests the public might be intentionally convinced that the revision is not urgent, while the draft is being discussed behind closed doors, only to be passed suddenly at the end of the year under the pretext of meeting election stages.
“Perhaps that is the strategy. It is told to the public that it hasn’t been discussed, when in fact, closed-door discussions may already be occurring, only to be suddenly ratified with the excuse of urgency because the recruitment stages for election organisers must proceed by the end of the year,” Jeirry explained.
Jeirry further requested that DPR Commission II open space for substantive dialogue with civil society groups from the beginning of the process, rather than merely conducting socialisation after the law has been finalised.
“Do not wait until it is finished to inform the public; that is not dialogue, but mere socialisation. We urge Commission II to begin discussions immediately because the current reasons are more than sufficient,” he concluded.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/observer-urges-house-commission-ii-to-immediately-discuss-election-law-revision-1781693450)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/901435/pengamat-minta-komisi-ii-dpr-segera-bahas-revisi-uu-pemilu), translated from Indonesian