Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Observer Urges Electronic Parking to Break the Chain of Illegal Parking

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Infrastructure
Observer Urges Electronic Parking to Break the Chain of Illegal Parking
Image: Media Indonesia

The crackdown on illegal parking and unauthorised parking attendants being intensified by the Jakarta Provincial Government is deemed ineffective at creating a deterrent effect if it relies solely on field raids and enforcement.

Urban planning expert Nirwono Joga assesses that illegal parking practices have evolved into an economic field worth hundreds of billions to trillions of rupiah, involving various parties, ranging from parking attendants and community groups to certain individuals who have long profited from the business.

“Fines, removing wheel nuts, or raids are merely temporary treatments. It will not be a deterrent if there is no comprehensive solution and a certain system to replace it,” Nirwono said today.

According to Nirwono, the vast economic potential of the parking sector is one of the main reasons illegal parking continues to emerge despite repeated enforcement efforts. He noted that calculations estimate the potential parking revenue in Jakarta reaches between Rp500 billion and Rp1 trillion per year.

However, that figure mostly reflects the legal parking sector. Illegal parking activities scattered across various points in the city are believed to have a much larger economic value, although they have never been precisely mapped.

“If we look around, there is actually more illegal parking than legal parking. This potential, I believe, must be considered because in the future, it could become a significant source of Regional Original Income (PAD) for DKI Jakarta,” he said.

Nirwono believes that illegal parking has developed into an economic ecosystem involving many parties. Therefore, enforcement alone does not solve the problem as long as the source of income from these practices remains wide open.

“We know all illegal parking in Jakarta is managed. In quotes, it is carried out by certain parties, ranging from mass organisations, security elements, and other components that participate in taking a share,” he said.

Rather than relying on periodic enforcement operations, Nirwono believes the government must build a parking system capable of closing the loopholes that allow illegal parking to emerge. The first step is to increase adequate legal parking facilities. According to him, land limitations mean Jakarta has little choice but to build professionally managed multi-storey parking buildings.

In addition to infrastructure provision, digitalisation is an equally important factor. Nirwulating, Nirwono assesses that electronic parking systems and cashless payments are the most effective ways to cut revenue leakage and eliminate space for illegal levies. He cited business districts and shopping centres in Jakarta that have fully implemented digital parking systems without cash transactions.

“If the private sector can do it, why can’t the government? This implies there are other parties intentionally not optimising revenue digitally. In fact, electronic parking addresses two problems at once: illegal parking and illegal levies. Everything is recorded, so there is no revenue leakage,” he said.

To manage the parking sector more professionally, he proposed that the Jakarta Provincial Government form a special body in the form of a Regional Public Service Agency (BLUD) or a regional company. He believes such an institution could integrate parking management, from location planning and system digitalisation to supervision, to suppress revenue leakage and illegal parking practices.

“So, there is spatial planning, there are regulations, and there is monitoring. This should be a note for colleagues in the Regional House of Representatives (DPRD) who are forming a special committee on parking, to see that this can be one of the recommendations provided,” Nirwono said.

Nevertheless, he warned that the improvement of the parking sector should not be solely oriented towards increasing regional revenue. “The note is: do not focus solely on the money. Parking must serve as an instrument to reduce congestion, improve air quality, and encourage the public to switch to public transportation,” he concluded.

More from 15 June 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/observer-urges-electronic-parking-to-break-the-chain-of-illegal-parking-1781506232)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/megapolitan/900641/pengamat-dorong-parkir-elektronik-untuk-putus-mata-rantai-parkir-liar), translated from Indonesian
Print