Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Observer: Unlimited Terms for Village Heads Contradict Democracy

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Politics
Observer: Unlimited Terms for Village Heads Contradict Democracy
Image: Media Indonesia

M Jamiluddin Ritonga, a political communication observer from Esa Unggul University, believes that the proposal by the Association of Village Heads at the End of Term (Kades AMJ) to allow unlimited terms for village heads and to postpone village head elections (Pilkades) must be rejected.

According to Jamiluddin, this proposal contradicts the democratic principles adopted by Indonesia following the Reformation era. He stated that term limits are a vital component in preventing power from being concentrated within a single party for too long.

“Such proposals are only suitable for countries with closed or authoritarian systems. In such countries, terms can indeed be unlimited or even for life,” Jamiluddin told Media Indonesia on Saturday (12/9).

He emphasised that Indonesia has moved away from closed political systems and has chosen democracy as its system of government. Therefore, term limits should apply to all positions obtained through popular election, including village heads.

“Indonesia no longer adheres to a closed system. After the Reformation, the nation agreed and consented to an open system, or democracy,” he said.

Furthermore, Jamiluddin argued that the terms of village heads should ideally be limited, just like other political offices. He noted that if the presidential term is limited to a maximum of two periods, a similar principle should be applied to village heads.

“All positions elected by the people—starting from the President, Governors, Regents, or Mayors, to Village Heads—should be limited. If the presidential term is only allowed for two periods, then village heads should also be limited to two periods,” he asserted.

In his view, term limits are necessary to prevent the abuse of power, including practices of corruption and collusion. Power held for too long is seen as having the potential to create closed power networks that are difficult to monitor.

“Unlimited power tends to become absolute and triggers corruptive actions and collusion because a ‘comfort zone’ and closed power networks are established,” he said.

Beyond the issue of corruption, Jamiluddin assessed that excessively long terms could encourage authoritarian leadership practices. In such conditions, the control over power holders risks weakening.

“Positions held for too long can also foster authoritarian practices. Long-term control of power risks birthing an authoritarian leadership style, where criticism is silenced and law enforcement weakens,” he noted.

He also warned of other impacts, such as the hindrance of innovation and leadership regeneration. Leaders who remain in the same position for too long are considered at risk of losing flexibility in facing change.

“Officials or leaders who remain in the same position for too long often lose flexibility, new ideas, and fail to adapt to the changing times,” said Jamiluddin.

Furthermore, he assessed that term limits are necessary to open space for a new generation. Regeneration, according to him, is a vital part of maintaining government dynamics and encouraging the emergence of new ideas.

“Remaining in the same position continuously closes the door for new talent or the next generation to bring about renewal,” he remarked.

Jamiluddin also emphasised that excessively long terms have the potential to cause fatigue in performing duties. A routine without new challenges can impact the motivation and productivity of leaders.

“A decline in motivation and productivity can occur due to monotonous routines without new challenges,” he said.

Therefore, Jamiluddin reiterated that the proposal for unlimited village head terms must be rejected. He argued that such a policy is not only inconsistent with democratic principles but also has the potential to cause various problems in village governance.

“The proposal for unlimited village head terms must be rejected. This is not only inconsistent with the will of democracy but also brings many negative impacts,” he concluded.

More from 12 September 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/observer-unlimited-terms-for-village-heads-contradict-democracy-1789185110)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/932538/pengamat-masa-jabatan-kades-tak-terbatas-bertentangan-dengan-demokrasi), translated from Indonesian
Print