Observer: Police Involvement in Civilian Posts Is Natural and Lawful
If police personnel are indeed more competent for certain positions within the civilian realm, there is no need for us to harbour undue prejudice against the Polri institution.
Jakarta (ANTARA) - Senior political observer Boni Hargunds assesses that the involvement of the Indonesian National Police (Polri) in civil positions is a natural and legitimate necessity.
“If police personnel are indeed more competent for certain positions within the civilian realm, there is no need for us to harbour undue prejudice against the Polri institution,” Boni stated in Jakarta on Saturday.
Furthermore, he noted that Polri, as part of civil society, also bears the responsibility to strengthen civil democracy.
To that end, he urged the public to eliminate negative prejudices against Polri being permitted to occupy civil positions within relevant government agencies and ministries.
These provisions specifically target various positions deemed to require human resources from the police institution, based on both technical competence and institutional aspects.
Boni reaffirmed his confidence in Polri’s commitment to improving the performance and culture of the police institution, particularly in carrying out its various functional duties as the guardian of public order and security.
He specifically referred to the statement by the Chief of National Police, General Listyo Sigit Prabowo, who emphasised that the provision for Polri’s involvement in civil servant positions is not compulsory, but is entirely based on real needs and concrete requests from the relevant agencies or ministries.
“The Chief of Police’s argument demonstrates Polri’s commitment to maintaining and respecting the democratic culture within the framework of the Indonesian rule of law,” he said.
He argued that there are three conditions that need to be considered in implementing the provision for Polri to occupy civil positions. First, the existence of technical competence.
He assessed that competency-based placement is natural and legitimate if Polri personnel indeed possess relevant expertise for certain positions within the civilian environment.
Second, the nature must be non-coercive. A mechanism based on request rather than forced placement, he said, is considered an adequate safeguard against the dominance of the police institution over the civilian bureaucracy.
The third condition, he continued, is that the implementation of this provision must be carried out within the context of civil responsibility.
“Polri, as an integral part of civil society, is viewed as having a constitutional responsibility to contribute to the strengthening of democracy, rather than merely being a law enforcement institution,” said Boni.
Boni also expanded his argument into the broader geopolitical and economic context. He asserted that Indonesia is currently in a phase that requires thorough consolidation from all components of the nation.
He explained that this context covers two main dimensions: the need to ensure the success of the government agenda of President Prabowo Subianto and Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka, and the necessity of facing the complex implications of global economic and political volatility, which also impacts Indonesia’s domestic situation.
Within this framework of thought, he believes that scepticism towards Polri, or towards various other institutions, is no longer relevant to current conditions.
“All elements of the nation currently understand the essence of civil democracy and realise how important it is to prioritise democratic principles in the execution of the duties and functions of every institution within the Indonesian political system,” Boni emphasised.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/observer-police-involvement-in-civilian-posts-is-natural-and-lawful-1781967098)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5616316/pengamat-pelibatan-personel-polri-dalam-jabatan-sipil-wajar-dan-sah), translated from Indonesian