Observer Highlights Illicit Enrichment Discourse in Asset Forfeiture Bill, Urges Parliament to Exercise Caution
The discussions surrounding the Asset Forferessure Bill (RUU Perampasan Aset) continue to evolve, particularly regarding the proposal to include clauses concerning wealth that increases drastically without a clear origin, known as ‘illicit enrichment’.
Responding to this development, Public Policy Observer and Professor at Trisakti University, Prof. Trubus Rahardiansah, has urged lawmakers to avoid being reckless. He believes that blending legal concepts without a mature framework could ultimately backfire.
“One of the substantive issues that needs to be clearly distinguished is illicit enrichment, or wealth increases that cannot be reasonably explained,” Trubus stated in a briefing on Saturday, 26 September 2026.
Trubus highlighted a potential bias in understanding the difference between seizing assets derived from crime and creating entirely new criminal offences. He emphasised the importance of separating procedural law from substantive law.
“There is a push to include this issue within the Asset Forfeiture Bill. However, we must be careful to distinguish between substantive criminal law and formal criminal law,” he continued.
Philosophically, the Asset Forfeiture Bill is designed to simplify the state’s ability to reclaim assets resulting from criminal activities.
“Conceptually, the Asset Forfeiture Bill focuses heavily on the mechanisms or procedures the state uses to seize assets related to criminal acts. This means the primary focus lies on the procedural aspects of law enforcement,” said Trubus.
However, he warned that if illicit enrichment is forced into the bill, it would essentially be creating a new form of crime with much more complex regulations.
“Meanwhile, if illicit enrichment is to be established as a new criminal offence subject to punishment, the issue enters the realm of substantive criminal law. We would be discussing which acts are declared criminal, who can be held accountable, the elements of the crime, and what sanctions can be imposed,” he added.
Furthermore, Trubus asserted that this warning is closely linked to the reality of law enforcement on the ground, rather than being merely an academic debate.
“This distinction is not just an academic debate,” he said. He cautioned about the potential for human rights violations if the rules regarding the burden of proof for wealth are not formulated with precision.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/observer-highlights-illicit-enrichment-discourse-in-asset-forfeiture-bill-urges-parliament-to-exercise-caution-1790481131)
Originally published by VIVA.co.id (https://www.viva.co.id/berita/nasional/1931390-pengamat-soroti-wacana-illicit-enrichment-di-ruu-perampasan-aset-ingatkan-dpr-hati-hati), translated from Indonesian