Observer Claims Proposed 5% Parliamentary Threshold Contradicts Constitutional Court Ruling
Political communication observer from Esa Unggul University, M. Jamiluddin Ritonga, has criticised the agreement among political parties in President Prabowo Subianto’s governing coalition to push for an increase in the parliamentary threshold (PT) to 5% for the 2029 General Election.
Jamiluddin considers the proposal to raise the figure from 4% to 5% to be irrational and contrary to the spirit of Constitutional Court Decision Number 116/PUU-XXI/2023. “Increasing the PT beyond 4% appears to be a counter-logic that is difficult for common sense to accept. Because by raising the PT, the number of wasted votes will inherently increase,” Jamiluddin stated in Jakarta on Wednesday (16/9).
He was responding to statements by Gerindra Party Secretary-General Sugiono, who revealed that the coalition parties supporting President Prabowo Subianto have agreed on the 5% figure. According to Jamiluddin, this agreement is highly likely to be ratified by the House of Representatives (DPR), given that the PDI Perjuangan has historically also desired a relatively high threshold. “Therefore, the political parties in Senayan appear to be in unanimous agreement regarding a 5% PT. Such a threshold is quite safe for the parties currently established in Senayan,” said Jamiluddin.
Jamiluddin reminded that the primary consideration of the Constitutional Court in declaring the 4% threshold conditionally unconstitutional was to suppress the large number of wasted votes that are not converted into DPR seats. He revealed that during the 2024 legislative election, the number of invalid/wasted votes reached approximately 17.3 million, equivalent to 11.4% of the total 151.7 million national valid votes.
“The Constitutional Court assessed that a 4% PT lacks legitimacy because it harms the principle of people’s sovereignty. If a 5% PT is eventually approved, the number of wasted votes is certain to increase further,” he explained.
According to Jamiluddin, if lawmakers truly intend to follow up on the Constitutional Court’s verdict and respect voter aspirations, the parliamentary threshold should ideally be set below 4%. “Following the logic of the Constitutional Court’s decision, the PT should be below 4%. If this is realised, the number of wasted votes can be reduced and electoral justice can be achieved,” he concluded.
Previously, the Secretary-General of the Gerindra Party, Sugiono, confirmed that there was a meeting between the chairpersons of the political parties in President Prabowo Subianto’s governing coalition to discuss the revision of the Election Law (RUU Pemilu). During the meeting, Sugiono mentioned that the Gerindra Party agrees with the proposal for a parliamentary threshold of 5% for the upcoming election.
“One thing that seems to be agreed upon—though I cannot speak on behalf of other parties—is that Gerindra also agrees on a 5% PT. As Golkar and PKS also expressed yesterday, I believe that is what we have agreed upon,” Sugiono said at the Parliament Complex, Senayan, Central Jakarta, on Wednesday (16/9).
In addition to agreeing on the parliamentary threshold percentage, the discussion on the Election Law revision focused on three areas: increasing election efficiency, improving implementation effectiveness, and safeguarding voter votes to prevent them from being wasted.
“The essence is how this election can be more efficient and effective, and how the remaining people’s votes can still be well-accommodated. Because ultimately, those are their voices and aspirations,” he added.
Regarding the timeline for discussing the Election Law revision in Commission II of the DPR RI, Sugiono stated that the coalition parties are still finalising the schedule for follow-up meetings to establish a final agreement before entering the legislative process in the DPR RI. “That is what was discussed yesterday. Ultimately, there will be an agreement; we will gather again. But we do not know when, whether it will be this year or next year; we shall see,” he concluded.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/observer-claims-proposed-5-parliamentary-threshold-contradicts-constitutional-court-ruling-1789559794)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/934117/pengamat-sebut-usulan-ambang-batas-parlemen-5-persen-tabrak-putusan-mk), translated from Indonesian